L'Oreal ParisMakeup Voluminous Original Volume Building Waterproof Mascara, Black Brown, 1 Count

This has been my go-to for over a decade with no problems until I ordered it from Amazon. It began clumping within a week and was dried out after 2 weeks. It usually lasts 3-4x longer.This inventory must have been a knockoff, an outdated discount batch for Amazon, or been sitting in the warehouse a long time because I got another from the drugstore and it worked beautifully as usual for over 6 weeks.It’s not a bargain if it’s already defective, and can’t be returned, so I won’t be ordering cosmetics from Amazon anymore.The title says it all, and I’m hard to please. No “melting” or smearing, the brush calibrates the application for reaching every lash and building to your desired effect, it stands up to a full day of work or play, and doesn’t irritate my eyes.

I’ve been using L'Oréal Waterproof Mascara for years, and it’s still my go-to! It provides incredible volume and length, instantly enhancing my lashes. The waterproof formula truly stays put all day, even through rain or tears, without smudging or flaking. It’s easy to apply, separates lashes beautifully, and washes off easily at the end of the day. I love that I have it on auto-ship — I never run out! Reliable, durable, and always high quality — a staple in my makeup routine. Highly recommend!

Separates fairly well. Gives volume and length fairly well. Removes with makeup remover fairly well. Normal mascara problems that all mascara seems to have. It works but somehow it could be better... Not sure why better still doesn't exist.

New favorite mascara?I’ve always loved big lashes- as I get older, the brown looks so much better. Can go from natural looking to adding more so that it’s more dramatic.Washes off well. Usually have to clean up after I shower to get the remaining leftover mascara.Wore daily in Disney World in over 100 heat and didn’t run at all!Will be purchasing again!

Seems to a little on the dry side. Maybe old??

i've tried dozens of mascaras, but I always come back to this one. i actually use it on my very pale (almost invisible) eyebrows - one swoop, and bang, they look great. Never clumpy or thick -- perfect brush -- my lashes and brows are ready to go in record time.

This is nice mascara I used to buy it with the white stuff together that makes your lashes look bigger, but I had to buy them separate. I don't have big lashes so have to put a couple coats on. I wish I could purchase the set together. It's hard to put on false eyelashes with my old eyes, and I don't really like the looks of them, they look too much like stage makeup. This mascara with the white undercoat is helpful and looks more natural.

I have used this product before, from a local store.I opened it, tried to use it, but the mascara is extremely dry. I had to run it under hot water to soften it.Needs multiple layers, and is waterproof.The back panel says it removes with soap and water. Difficult to remove.This product comes with a label- cannot be returned. I now have 2 tubes of useless mascara.