Full description not available
A**N
A great finale in a less than great pentalogy
I became a 55 year old Black Jack fanboy from the first pages of the first book of the first hexalogy. Dauntless made me stay up almost all night, glued to the book pages like some silly activist glued to a Vermeer painting. And then, after staying up almost all night, I stayed up some more to give the writer a blazing 5 stars review.Now, eleven books later, it’s time to give a second review on the second pentalogy. To start bluntly, it’s not as stratospheric as the first one. Being familiar with Xenophon’s Anabasis and “Thalatta, Thalatta”, I was instantly dialed in the first series’ premise. More important, I really liked the manifestation of this world, with its relativity rules, space maneuvers, petty officers and petty admirals, stratagems, romances, gambits, tricks, deceits and respect for their ancestors.The second pentalogy, however, even though it has its moments, could never have passed over the bar of Dauntless, Fearless, Courageous, Valiant, Relentless and Victorious, as through most of the books, the writer goes a little bit too much through the motions. Geary will meet his captains in the usual special room with the projections, he will ask guidance from his ancestors, he will try to understand Tanya Desjani’s scorn for Victoria Rione – all these seem a little bit too much like rounding up the usual suspects, with the addition of some aliens.However, the writer owed to his fans something more than this. And boy, how he delivered on the last novel, where for the first time in what seems like an eternity, Black Jack has finally met his match. There is a sense of impending doom, like the Moria drums in the deep, which becomes edgy and crushing as the story progresses. This final clash with Black Jack versus an AI fleet gone rogue is also the longest space fight described in the whole 11 novels, and it is worth every page of it.So, this is how the Lost Fleet Part II ends – not with a whimper, but with a big bang. And guess what, there are more novels in the pipeline for Black Jack’s fans, a new trilogy (Outlands) that will be completed in July 2023. I guess this fanboy will have to write one more review.
K**R
Very good reading. Without any doubt one of the better books in this series.
My review of the previous instalment in this series was less than stellar. It was luckily not a bad book but, nonetheless, my disappointment with this series have been growing since some time. Therefore I am quite happy that, to me, this book represents a big improvement compared to the previous books.One of my gripes with the previous books have been the unbelievable obstructionism and stupidity of the useless politicians, their endless machinations and how great a role this played in the story. Another one was the lack of direction. Geary was simply solving one problem after another that was thrown at him and a goal to strive for was sorely missing.Happily this is not the case with this book. Sure, the utterly useless politicians are very present in this book as well but this time they are finding themselves trapped in the hole that they themselves have dug. Not only that but in said hole there are a whole lot of sh-t sandwiches that they also made themselves and now they are all forced to take a bite. Naturally it is Geary and the men and women serving under him that have to pay the biggest price for the politicians stupidity but, at least, it is a somewhat humbling experience for these a--holes and, as it turns out, there are one or two of them that are not as useless and morally corrupt as the rest of the f--kers.The book also have a clear goal. The path to said goal have a few twists along the way but there is no mystery about what Geary have to achieve. How he is supposed to achieve it, well that is not so clear until after quite a few revelations, twists and a LOT of action.Some of the aliens, the “Dancers”, the friendly ones, that Geary had encountered during his adventures are back and they do indeed play a rather crucial role in how things play out. I quite liked this since I felt that all those aliens that Geary encountered were kind of left out of the story arc in the previous book. Not wanting to leave too many spoilers around but the communications between the “Dancers” and the humans do improve quite substantially which in turn improves the changes for Geary to succeed in his quest by an equally substantial amount.As usual the writing is very good, the characters are well done and the action, the manoeuvres in space and the combat physics are really, really good. Speaking of combat, the losses on both sides are quite staggering and this is one thing that annoys me somewhat with this series so far. Not that there are losses in combat but in every book Geary’s fleet is whittled down by a fairly substantial amount and nothing is really replaced except possibly for Geary getting some already worn out leftovers. I really hope that we are going to see Geary getting some new hardware sooner or later. Especially since, in previous books, Geary encountered quite a few hostile species and I certainly hope that, when the formerly mentioned politicians, climb out of their self-made sh-thole that they actually start to use whatever brain cells they might have left and actually consider this threat to humanity.The ending, although generally on a positive note, is not entirely a happy one. There are sacrifices that have been made and several characters that have been with us for some time are written off which saddens me somewhat.It took me some time to get around to read this book after having purchased it due to my disappointment with the previous instalments but after having read it I have to say that I was quite happy with this one and I am now looking forward to the next instalment. I certainly hope the author continues on this path and, above all, keeps the political stupidity toned down. After all, if I wanted to read about political stupidity all I need to do is open a newspaper and read about the latest nonsense from the EU oxygen wasters.
G**T
but it certainly feels like a series finale
I sat down last night to read a few chapters of this while I ate dinner.The next thing I knew, it was dark outside, the book was done, and I was wondering where the next one was.Extremely well written, extremely well paced, and wraps up most of the loose ends of the series. Not sure if this is the final Lost Fleet book, but it certainly feels like a series finale.If this is the final Lost Fleet book, it's a worthy capstone!
Y**S
The Lost Fleet 5
- 商品は、思っていたより早く到着。ありがとうございます- 本の内容は、もうマンネリもいいとこなので、まったくの初めてこのシリーズを読む人か、これに遣ってしまった人におすすめ。
P**E
Continues to Entertain
Continues to entertain, the introduction of new characters and new adversaries helps it to remain enjoyable. Not earth shattering but still very good.I will look forward to more works from the Author.
P**M
Black Jack did it again
If Jack Campbell wrote it, I would give 5 stars to a grocery list. This book is part of a larger series and you should start at the beginning novel and you won't be sorry. Every is a good read
L**T
Good reads
Excellent entertainment and wonderful escapism. Great author
Trustpilot
3 weeks ago
2 weeks ago