HAUS LABORATORIESby Lady Gaga: EYE-DENTIFY GEL PENCIL EYELINER, Hunted

Tried this bec. hadn't seen these before. Pencil is very soft and goes on easily with terrific color payoff. Gorgeous shade which is flattering to any complexion. Not too overt -just gorgeous.

You CAN sharpen it! I thought it was plastic, but it worked in a pencil sharpener. Fabulous color, and it doesn't smudge after wear, it's really nice quality.

First, I do experience some smudging on my lower waterline- if I wear any on that area- but I normally just wear it on the top lid. And I’ve always had issues with pencils and my lower line, no matter how good the quality, so that's not unusual for me. Also, using a good primer and shadow with this helped a lot.That said, it is actually a great product, I love wearing this as a shadow on my top lids. It glides on so smooth and creamy and the shade of green is gorgeous and stays great up there.

Easy, thin line, thick line -- and you can't beat the in cap sharpener. This is the ONLY eye liner I love.

It’s super smooth and very black, easy to use and very “slippery”, so it’s easy to draw a wing! Great value for the money. I bought it while they were re-branding

Second time I bought this product. I love the color, how it blends and stays on even longer with eyelid primer.

Like any makeup this one has pros & cons. Pros are that the color is well pigmented and true, and that it gently glides on. The cons are that it smears quite easily, has a very short lifespan on your lids, and is not very waterproof at all. I'm an allergy sufferer so my eyes water constantly. This did not hold well. I tried 2 different methods: My right eye below is applied with primer 1st, then light setting spray, then I ran the pencil thru setting spray, then applied. The left eye below was applied only with primer 1st. Neither method worked well although the 1st was slightly better.

The crayon part of the pencil falls out of the pencil entirely. In addition the crayon part is about one third of the length of the pencil. Terrible product.