SEPHORACOLLECTION Retractable Waterproof Eyeliner #10 Matte Brown Black

Easy to put on, waterproof, little to no smudging (unless you rub your eyes).

Usually I use pencil and just soften it with a lighter because most eyeliners smudge and run so I was happy that I didn't have to use the lighter and it didn't run or smudge. 12 hours after applying and still looks great. Went on smooth and easy this will be my new favorite

This is the best eyeliner I have ever used. It is certainly worth the extra $$. Other pencils faded off or smeared, but this one stays put and stays dark. I do not like the "ink" on eyeliner and like the "pencil" look (it looks more dramatic and not "drawn on"), so this is perfect. Since eyeliner is the only makeup I wear most of the time, it is worth it to get a good brand, and this is it!-Tania

I heard about this on a Makeup video on You tube. I love it. It goes on so nice and does not smudge. Perfect for traveling as the tops stay on and it gives a perfect line all the time.

I prefer liquid eyeliner, but I'm determined to master a pencil. (With a liquid eyeliner, I can easily draw a thin line. With a pencil, I can't seem to do that.) I chose this eyeliner, because it's creamy & waterproof. (Made in Germany)

I've used it for a long time it's great it goes on perfect stays on till you take it off and the actual container lasts a good significant amount of time

I don't remember paying $12 + s/h for this eyeliner, I believe it was quite a bit less when I ordered it 6 months ago...However, this is the ONLY pencil eyeliner that I have used that will last through Midwest humidity and swimming. (Loreal has a close runner up.) I tried at least a dozen "waterproof" and/or "smudgeproof" last year, and was thrilled to finally find this one.If someone has another brand they recommend, please add a comment and pass on your recommendation. :)

This eyeliner is perfect for me and I purchased this one because it is easy and quick to apply, it is one of the very few products that does not irritate my eyes. I was buying from the Sephora site but it is the exact same product with a better price from Amazon.