Full description not available
W**L
As good as it gets
A classic! Great military history for anyone. Expertly written, fact checked, really a must read ww2 work. Amazing story of brave men.
J**N
Much more detail than Mini Series
Decided to read this after watching the HBO mini series for the "100th" time. A great read and provides many factual details not in mini series. Ironically - it did not detract from what the mini series presents. Normally a book is much better than the movie - and this is a great book. Both are equally enjoyable.
D**S
Good Read
A really well done history. An easy read and I'm glad to have read it. I enjoyed the focus on a company rather than an overview. It was a very different experience to get to know the men who served in WW2
J**E
good read for fans of the show
If you are a fan of the hbo series I imagine you will be of this book. Certain events are slightly different but the core of it is all there.
D**L
History Up Close and Personal
What happens if you throw a diverse group of young men together, give them all guns, make them run their butts off for a year or so and learn to shoot said guns and work as a team, then drop them out of airplanes over Hitler's Europe and tell them to start shooting bad guys?Stephen Ambrose tells the remarkable true story of E Company, just such a group of guinea pigs. E Company fought with distinction at Normany and in Holland, plugged a key gap in the Battle of the Bulge, and was in on the rather haphazard, MASHian ramsacking of the remains of Hitler's little paradise in the Bavarian clouds.The heart and soul of E Company was Dick Winters, a soft-spoken, teatotalling (NOT the norm) and kindly CO who works his way up to major by war's end, and who had the occasional Seargent York / Incredible Hulk moments, when Germans fall to the dozen. But after Winters has been promoted out of (much) direct action, Ambrose's spotlight falls more commonly upon the NCOs who provide the backbone of the company from the Battle of the Bulge on. Ambrose sugar-coats nothing: he relates acts of cruelty, drunken folly (too many to count), random acts of fate, and sheer stupidity, injustice, corruption (the front-line troops were robbed blind, and they robbed the locals), and incompetence. Though I have to say, Winters is the only character who really comes alive for me, along with a young writer from Harvard who refuses to be promoted, but does his job and writes competently about what he sees. (I think Ambrose exagerates his talent a bit, but that's fine -- he was at the right place at the right time with a competent pen, that's good enough.) Also Lieutenant Sobel, the hard-case CO against whom the troops rebel, and who gets left behind in England, and grows bitter. The others have their moments on stage, exit left, and are gone. By the end of the book, it's a bit hard to keep track. One comes to realize that with its high casualty and replacement rate, Company E has pretty much replaced all its original cells and we're talking about a new group of men almost entirely.Ambrose was not, in my opinion, a great styllist. I was reading Tom Wolfe's The Right Stuff at the same time I read this, and there is no comparison. Wolfe is truly brilliant. What Ambrose succeeds at most remarkably, is his act of historical reconstruction. This book involved interviewing survivors of E Company on or about 1990, some 45+ years after the fact, along with relentless gathering, reading, and sifting of written reports.As an historian of religion, I found the undeniable success of Ambrose's methodology particularly interesting. Some skeptics claim that the human memory is too frail a reed, too unreliable and suggestible, for historical reports written decades after the fact to be trustworthy. I think Ambrose shows them wrong. Given that the gospels were written under somewhat similiar circumstances -- 35-60 years after the fact, based apparently on the eyewitness testimony of many once young men (mostly) who had traveled together for a few years and experienced and witnessed traumatic and remarkable events -- I think Ambrose's success (despite occasionally contradictory sources) should give those skeptics pause.Read the book, and experience World War II from the front lines, as it was really fought. (Without needing to sleep in frozen foxholes with artillery rounds blowing up trees over your head.) Highly recommended. (Along with Tom Wolfe's The Right Stuff.)
D**N
Great book (but bad Kindle edition)
This is the book that HBO based their "Band of Brothers" mini-series on, and it was excellent. I had already seen the mini-series, which was also excellent, so I was in a position similar to times when you see the movie and then go read the book.If you never saw it or have no idea what I'm talking about, this is the story of the men of Easy company, a group of 150 soldiers from the 101st Airborne division in World War II. It follows them from their training in the US through D-Day, the Battle of the Bulge and their defense of Bastogne, on into Germany, and their victory lap at Hitler's very own Eagle's Nest. For the most part, they were not career military men. They were merely citizens who went off to war.As an aside, books get turned into movies all the time, and if you read the book first, you then decry how much they cut to squeeze it all into the 2-hour movie. If you see the movie first, the book is then filled with all this extra stuff like backstory, extra plot-lines, and character depth. But a book and a mini-series are a good fit.HBO gave it ten hour-long episodes and managed to cover most of the book, so while I wasn't coming across tons and tons of new material, there were still plenty of newfound gems. More than anything, it was like reading the director's commentary of the DVD, except of course, it wasn't the director. In many cases, it was direct quotes from many of the soldiers who had fought through the war. It also had a bit of surreal sense in that I felt like I already knew these people and had clear pictures of them in my mind. All in all, seeing the series before-hand made reading the book that much more enjoyable.One section that was in the book that the mini-series only glossed over was what these remarkable soldiers did with their lives after the war. A large number of them went into teaching, and another big bunch of them went into construction. That was a nice turn, seeing them go from a world of destruction and violence to a life of building the future.I'm going to quote one little bit from those later years that really made an impression on me. Private Ralph Stafford wrote, "In 1950, I went bird hunting with some guys from the fire department. I shot a bird and was remorseful as I looked down at it. The bird had done me no harm and couldn't have. I went to the truck and stayed until the others returned, never to hunt again." He had had enough of killing.It looks like a number of these soldiers went on to write and publish their own memoirs of the war, but this is the place to start.My only negative comment about the book was that the Kindle edition (which is what I read) was a terrible e-book conversion. There were some glitches that looked like lost words, bad text conversions like 2nd to 2d, and the index was a worthless list of topics not linked back to any location in the book. Bad Publisher - No Donut! So if you want to read this, get it in a dead-tree edition.
Trustpilot
2 weeks ago
3 weeks ago