e.l.f.Cookies 'N Dreams No Budge Shadow Stick, Longwear, Smudge-Proof Eyeshadow With Built-In Sharpener, Limited Edition Shade, Midnight Milkshake

Like how easy it is to use and the color is perfect.

Lasts long. Good color. Smooth feeling. Good blending. Thick color.

I’ve never reviewed an eyeshadow before because they don’t tend to work well on my hooded, middle-age eyes. To my absolute shock, this is easy to apply, goes on smoothly, and stays put. I got the cookies and cream, which is a rich black. The only thing I don’t like is the occasional gold sparkle. It’s not sparkly throughout, just a random spot here and there. Take out the glitter and it’s perfect.

Works great as an eyeliner!

Great color and price. The packaging is also very cute. Sometimes it fades if I use a light hand, but if I’m heavier-handed, it will stay on all day.

I've tried pencil cream shawdows before and usually they don't adhere to my skin and can't even tell I put it on, but this is the first one that works for me.

I loved this, but actually used it as an eyeliner. It stays on well. Very well. However. Do not drop it on the ground, because if your hubby steps on it, it will break and he will track it all over your floor and it's pretty much nonremovable! And then you'll need to get another one. Lol.

It’s a light eye liner