ValueBull Beef Gullet Sticks for Dogs, 100 Count Bulk Pack - Premium Dog Chews, Dog Joint Health Glucosamine Jerky, Puppy Teething Treat, Beef Esophagus Dog Treats, Chondroitin Joint Support

My dogs love these. They don't last long for either of my two dogs (70lb adult and 70lb 7mnth old puppy), but no other snack is more beloved. It's cheaper for me to buy these in bulk. Compared to other options this is a good value for the money. Smaller dogs probably won't go through these as quick as my two. The size is consistent and my dogs love the smell and taste of these things. It's like dog-candy, if candy had protein and satisfied the urge to chew. I used these as a reward when training my dogs to give me things they were chewing on and like. Now I can take anything from either without them making a fuss. Of course, they do expect a reward for their efforts. That's not the worst problem to have though.

The dogs love them, but oh boy they smell SO bad…

My fault for not reading the description of the product or name. They look like bully sticks but are NOT. They are hollow not solid. My dog chews through them in minutes. So not worth the price!

Dogs love them, smell is not as strong as some other brands -- just keep them in a sealed container, cost effective and delivered in a timely fashion. Appreciate the care that seems to have gone into this product by the producers. Really recommend these.

A great value of treats for the dollar but wear rubber gloves as they smell really bad! No joke.

Was hoping these were like shorter 'bull sticks', but they're more like treats (20 seconds, vs. a few minutes)The dogs liked them, but they're not really in the 'chewing treat' category as much as a quick snack treat.

My new puppy gets these so he won't chew inappropriate things. So far very successful.

Good size for a contented chew at bed time or any crate time