COLORKEYFloating Color 24 Hours Longwear Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner, Sweat Resistant, Waterproof and Smudgeproof Eye Liners Eyeliner Pencil (N01 Black)

After my felt tip liner was discontinued, I needed a new eyeliner. I'm very picky and skeptical when it comes to felt tips, because my eyelids can get easily irritated depending on what the felt tip is made with, but I'm so happy this worked out for me. I love how easily the ink glides on and it doesn't run down after it's been applied. I got both the N01 Black and No5 Azure. I'm in love with the Azure liner! I'm only giving it a 4, because I had to every now and then shake up the liner and sometimes it still wouldn't apply, unless I applied a little bit of pressure. I know I'm not the only one who had this issue, but maybe I'm doing something wrong, so if anyone or if the seller has any suggestions on how to avoid this, just let me know. Thank you!

Purchased the Colorkey in brown and was excited to try it. Used it at home and the brown color was just a regular medium brown. (I prefer dark brown). Wore it to the gym and sweated a lot and most of it was gone by the time I was done working out. I dab at my face to wipe away sweat instead of rubbing my face. The eyeliner didn't prove to be waterproof nor smudge proof.Today I wore on my bare eyes and it started to smudge off without me doing anything. Had a cry session (no bawling, but many tears) and most was gone without me even touching my eyes. After application, I am able to easily rub it off with my fingers.Love the brush - hence the 2 stars. It makes for very easy application. It gave me the easiest cat eyes I've even drawn. However, I can't depend on it to stay on for a whole day.

Wow! This eyeliner is almost perfect!! Came sealed well, upon using, super easy glide and very easy to do a good cat eye. Not an issue per se but after filling in, will need to shake it up then continue. True black, easy glide, easy point, firm yet flexible tip. Very impressed with this liner. Love the bearing in the pen that provides the physical sensation of the shake and mix. Not all similar liners provide that which can be confusing or doubt that the tip and liquid is being mixed and the tip "refilled".

I was a little nervous the first time I used this, because it's very different than my previous eyeliner. But even though it takes a steady hand to apply, it goes on so smoothly! And it lasts a LOT longer than my old "crayon" style liner. I'd say it lasts about 10 hrs.

This is my new favorite liquid liner!! I ordered the Berry Red and the color payoff is awesome! I am African American with a light/medium olive complexion (MAC NC43 for reference). The Berry Red shows up great on me, unlike some luxury brands that disappear as soon as they dry. I will definitely order other colors!!