Maybelline TattooStudio Eyeliner Makeup Pencil, Effortlessly Glide On Smooth Gel Pigments With 36 Hour Wear, Waterproof, No Smudging, No Flaking, Smooth Walnut, 0.04 Oz

I just like it I can’t say I love it cuz when rubbing it with water it did fade but when just applying water to it without rubbing it it did stay as when I use it!!

For me this is the best pencil eyeliner...it stays on all day...tried others , but for me personally it is great..you must keep it sharp , as it is goes on easily..and you must have a good cleaning cloth to remove..love it.

I have very watery eyes but I love to wear eyeliner so it's hard to find one that works. I first tested this one by drawing a line in the crease of my thumb since eyes have folds. I rinsed it under water and rubbed it and it didn't come off. It's very rare that eyeliner passes this test.Of course it works on your eyes too 😉 love it

The pencil itself is great! Long wearing, even on the waterline, stays on all day and it doesn't irritate my eyes.It worked great until I had to sharpen it. The khol is so soft it would break off inside my sharpener and the cause the wood from the pencil to cut my eyelid. Could just be the eye pencil sharpener I was using... But I'll still to self sharpening pencils from now on.

I bought this few days ago, it worked well in the first few days of application and now it’s completely useless. It’s now like a crayon that can’t be used.