ValueBull Bully Stick Bits Dog Treats, 0-4 Inch, 5 Pounds - All Natural Dog Treats, 100% Beef Pizzles, Single Ingredient Rawhide Alternative

Dogs loved the thick pieces. They actually had to chew them for awhile. Have large dogs that are chewers. Gave them 3 or 4 pieces at a time. Great treat. The smell is bad(as are all bully sticks & pieces). I think this actually makes them more appealing to the dogs. I use these to help keep their teeth clean between dental cleanings at the vet. I buy the longer sticks when I need to keep the dogs occupied for some time. I liked the fact that not only does the package zip seal but there is an inner plastic bag that I twist around and put inside the zip seal outer bag (helps with the smell). Also, they come in individually packaged 1 lb bags (10 in all) so I only open 1 at a time and the rest stay fresh(stinky, depending on your point of view). Would definitely buy again as the dogs all seem to love them and have had no problems with diarrhea as can occur with some products of this nature.

Ohmigosh, what can I say about these "Stinky Sticks" except that my dog will roll over, play dead, shake, high five, and even come when I call her for one? All I have to do is shake the treat can.If you are a regular reader of my reviews, you are familiar with Pibbles, the Pit Bull Princess. The Princess will actually - hold your breath - B.E.H.A.V.E. for one of these little tidbits. Now, I hate to open the treat can I put them in, as they smell to high heaven, but these tiny pizzles just make her day. They are approximately 1/2" to 1" bully stick pieces, with the occasional smaller or larger to be found. Full size bully sticks are so terribly expensive, this is a way to stretch that price way out. Pibbles hardly knows the difference. Not sure she does at all. She truly loves them, large or small.I can't get her to leave them on the top of her head and wait, though...we're working on it. Unsuccessfully.

They absolutely reek. But the dogs love them and they are the perfect size for my beagles who can't seem to get enough of them. Perfect size for a treat as I'm walking out the door to keep them entertained . The downside is that they smell even when I return home.

Crazy cheap compared to other sellers. Good quality. My dogs love them. I prefer these smaller pieces so I can give them more often without breaking the bank. They are perfect for passing out to my dogs when I get home from work because then they can go lay down and chew on them for a minute and are much calmer greeting me when they are done with them. Mine came in 5 separate sealed bags which is great because since it takes me a while to go through them all, they stay fresh.

Word of caution, they smell like crap!!! what i do is dumb all of them in a ziplock freezer bag with a bag of activated charcol to help reduce the smell. The carcol is contained in its own pouch so its not in contact with the sticks, but in close proximity the charcol will absorbe the stink to a degree. Your dogs will thank you for these nasty things LOL!!!

They are the right size for a treat and the dogs love them.

They’re loved by my dogs but really stink but for the money they are awesome. Small size bu that means I can give several out all through the day!

Great value, but they smell SO bad.