Maybelline Gel Pencil Liner, Tattoo Eye Liner Quick Drying Eyeliner, Waterproof & Smudge-Proof – Semi-Permanent Tattoo, Long-Lasting Sharpenable with Built-in Sharpener, Shade: Bold Bronze

This eyeliner is very good, it glides on well and stays put so does not smudge, when I purchased I thought it was retractable but it isn't so I just sharpen it the same as a pencil liner, it's also a nice colour too.

This is remarkable. Totally waterproof - stayed on after a bike ride followed by a pool swim. To my understanding its formula contains polymer which hardens on application and stays where it needs to. This also prevents product from seeping into the eyelid glands and blocking them. I thought I had sensitive eyes but since switching to this all the problems with eye irritation disappeared. Note: to remove this you need an oil based eye make up remover such as Nivea Bi-Phase, which dissolves the waterproof polymer. Shake the remover until well mixed, dip a cotton bud in, and very slowly and gently move it along the closed eyelid to dissolve and wipe off the liner. (Then you'll need to use a cream cleanser to remove the oily remover!).

In my quest to find a smudge-proof and waterproof black eyeliner for my upper and lower waterlines I read the reviews and thought this would be worth a try. It’s a difficult one because it has stayed on, it hasn’t smudged and it is waterproof but it’s made my eyes water all day, even writing this nearly 12 hours after applying. So it does what it says on the tin but I suffer with dry eyes and think it’s aggravated that. Shame because it glides on easily and has a strong black colour, exactly what I was looking for. I’m going to persevere and see if my eyes adapt, fingers crossed. If not it’ll be another one in the reject pile and the quest continues.

I was looking forward to this long lasting glide on liner.It is nt easy for older ladies with older ladies watery eyes to not look like a panda or the liner disappears.This product is smooth to apply,does stay on and is easy.Mine was a dark grey I have white hair so maybe a dark blue would have been a better choice,but so far so good for the price

Nice product but when you have to sharpen it. I don't find it sharpens it well at all.

I bought the Maybelline Tattoo Gel Eyeliner Pencil and I have been really happy with it. The formula glides on smoothly without tugging, and it gives a rich, dark line that lasts throughout the day. It stays in place without smudging or fading, even when worn for long hours. I also like how easy it is to blend slightly if you want a softer look, but it still holds up well once set. The pencil is easy to use and perfect for everyday wear or a more dramatic look. Overall I think it’s excellent quality and great value for what you get. I would definitely recommend it.

Amazing and smooth I love it

Very very disappointed as when I finally got the plastic wrap off this pencil and removed the lid, the TINY nib part at the top was unattached to the pencil - so it was unusable ( no mechanism to wind up a new bit, there is no new bit) so the whole thing was wasted. Don’t buy!

Der beste Eyeliner. Tolle Farbe, angenehm zu tragen, verwischt nicht so leicht UND leicht aufzutragen

Easy to apply and lasts but no way to sharpen it

Der beste Kajal, den ich jemals benutzt habe !!! Präzise, gut deckend, lässt sich leicht auftragen und hält sehr lange ! Schade dass dieser Farbton aufgelassen wurde !

So soft, pure, and easy to use. I must say at one point I almost stopped using it because everytime I needed to sharpen it and bake I was done with one turn, the top breaks off. I tried again n again even bought another sharpener. It worked a couple times until more than half is gone and the rest of the inside pencil came out. I couldn't use it in full. for a couple of months I went thru 4 pencils and they all had the same issue. On my 5th now, all its all good so far

Super bon crayon