Black Garter Shirt Stays for Men Police & Military, Select Series, USA Made

I bought this product becuase it wraps around the thigh. The clamps are good and do stay clipped onto my shirt. Investing in quality is better than buying several cheaply made products. This shirt stay I consider quality. 5/5 stars given.

They seem of acceptable quality, and work as long as you adjust them right. My main issue with them, though, is I received 2 lefts instead of a left and a right. Make sure to check yours if you buy this.[Edit: as stated in the title, I contacted support and was sent replacements. Support was helpful and responded in a timely manner, as well as followed up with me after the replacement was shipped]

I really had high hopes for this product. I bought the garter-style shirt stays so that I wouldn't have the feel of having straps running down my legs. There are three main issues with these, each of which cost it a star in my review. It gained back a star for being made in the USA.First, I'm not a fat guy or a skinny guy. I'm about as medium as you can get. But the thigh-sizing for these stays is such that when it's set to the thinnest setting, it's barely small enough for me. If I were any skinnier, they wouldn't be snug around my legs at all.Second, whatever length you set the straps at, they will not stay at that length. For example, if you set the elastic to five inches, it will soon be at seven or eight inches.Finally, and this is the worst of it, the alligator clips don't hold very well. I was constantly having the clip become unattached and dangling down inside my pant leg.After putting up with these issues for a couple of months, I got a y-shaped model from a different company that uses a sliding-button mechanism instead of gator clips. That works much better, and I've gotten used to the straps running down my pant legs. Much better than an unattached, dangling strap.

Honestly...it does exactly what I want it for (keep my shirt tucked in) I can be a little uncomfortable sitting through a whole work day (if you work sitting most of the day). I would definitely recommend this item .

Don’t bother buying because they will pop off long before they hold a shirt down.

These work great! Wish I had looked into it years ago. My shirt usually comes untucked within 2 holes while playing golf. Yesterday, in a tournament my shirt stayed neatly tucked through the whole round! Didnt even know I was wearing them!

The clasps are outstanding and stay hooked on all day—I’ve had other brands that couldn’t handle repeated standing and sitting. They did start to hurt the other day, however, after 8-9 hours wear. It felt as though my legs had dried out and the fabric was cutting into my legs. I think they were too tight and I’d worn them too long

The ones that attach to your socks are uncomfortable when you sit down. These are much better. Strong clips have never fqiled on me either