2 Pack Volumizing Mascara for Older Women 60 Plus - Lengthening & Thickening Formula, Smudge-Proof, Clump-Free, Waterproof Mascara for Thin Lashes, Ultra-Defining Lash Lift for Mature Eyes (Black, 2)

It works! Hands down the messiest mascara I have ever used but worth it. It adds length abd fullness to my lashes. Just keep a q-tip close by to wipe under your eyes after applying because somehow it gets everywhere. Once it dries though, it doesn't budget. It's a little hard to wash off, but I like that. I use cleansing balm to remove it.

It seems very good. Doesn't run or smear!

I was suspicious of this from the first time i saw an ad on tiktok...but hey, at under $10 I'll try it...with thyroid eye disease and allergies, my eyes are ALWAYS watering. This makes finding a true waterproof mascara a challenge. This one did NOT meet the challenge!!! ***But, before I go into this crap more, let me say this for anyone considering this based on the "dual brush" statements:THERE ARE NOT 2 BRUSHES!!!! IT IS ONLY ONE BRUSH!!!!! ONE SINGLE BRUSH!!! STEP 1 JUST PULLS THE BRUSH THROUGH A TUBE WHICH PULLS OFF EXCESS PRODUCT!!! STEP 2 YOU GET ALL OF THE PRODUCT IN ALL ITS GLOOPY STICKY MESSINESS!!! ONE BRUSH PEOPLE, ONLY ONE BRUSH!!!! OPEN IT UP, PULL OUT THE STEP 1 BRUSH....NOW YOU SEE WHAT I MEAN???? Ok, now on we go....so using that one single brush....which I prefer to call a spoolie, you apply this crap...and you watch as it smears and drips down your cheeks if you even think of blinking! So now you go on to step 2, where you are going to have more product on that ONE spoolie...apply that..watch it smear and smear and...you getting the picture? I eventually got enough of it to stay on my lashes and I went out...and a breeze blew in my face...and there went my mascara...now I ooked like I was crying tears of ink or tar! To end my rant, I will give this stuff credit for being impossible to remove, from my shirt, my countertop, my washcloth and my sink!!! But on my lashes? Its only toooo happy to come off there!!! Don't fall for the hype given to this crap. Just don't!!! Its nothing but a messy disappointment and one I hope to save others from by not recommending this! The cheapest drugstore mascara will outperform this one!!

This has become my go to mascara. It definitely makes my lashes look longer and it looks like I have extensions on, but it is this mascara. Doesn't smudge and is waterproof for sure. I wash it off with a little facial lotions and a few strokes and it comes right off. It doesn't clump or pull my lashes off when I wash it off. Love it!

I think this will be my new regular mascara. Does it make my lashes UNBELIEVABLY crazy long and full?? No. But the results are REALISTIC, unlike the results on the ad. One of my pics has nothing, one pic has just Vibely upper and lower tube application, and the last, my preference, has Vibely upper and lower, and I used a tube of fibers from one of my previous 2 step products. The pic w both eyes is for a better idea from a distance, since that is what most people will see. And all have had an eyelash curler put to them. I really believe Vibely should sell their own tube of fibers to buy as an option to go with it. For the price (2/9$!?!?!), it is an amazing option. And versatile. A few things to consider though: -The mascara is INCREDIBLY WET. Like, the wettest mascara I have ever dealt with. -It can be difficult to remove completely, so I recommend using a makeup remover before your night skincare routine. -Make sure you do a final sweep, really well, under your eyes after applying and letting dry completely. I've noticed that the fibers, as well as some flecks of mascara, like to hang out in my under eye area. My under eye area is dark enough on its own, thank you very much! -For context, I am a 40yo female with incredibly short and light lashes. And am never frivelous with money, so I really appreciate a "worth your money" product. Family living/raising can be challenging to budget. -Only filter used was on the pic with 2 eyes, and I only hit the "vibrant" button. Hope this helps someone out there make a good decision on whether or not this product is the right fit!

It does make my lashes look longer overall when i use it; however very difficult & messy while trying to remove it from my lashes, even w/ waterproof eye makeup remover. Flakes all over my face & a lot of my lashes just fall out. Not so sure if its worth the hype....

Apparently, perimenopause has made my hair thin, including my lashes. I've always had nice full and long lashes, where basic mascara would do the trick. Lately it doesn't look like put anything one after 4-5 coats. After reading the reviews I gave it a try. LOVE IT!! I wanted a fiber mascara for fullness, this has the fibers inside so there is mo clumping. The second Pic is only 2 coats and I love it. My eyes water alot and there is no smudging and it stays on. I've tried Better Than Sex and other pricey brands. This is the one!

Not at all how it describes!! The mascara is a weird texture. It DOES in fact clump. Definitely not waterproof, smudges. And it's only ONE BRUSH. Not two. So I don't know what the difference is between step one and step two because there is no difference. Same brush for both steps. Did lengthen my eyelashes some but I'll stick to my other mascara for sure. Disappointed for sure.

Great quality , cheaper than paying $60 for another brand that is the same

Okey ! Listen to me on this ! Don't get fast eyelashes in the salon and pay so much 💰💰 This mascara does the job for a very affordable price ! 💳 * When you get this mascara, you have to get a waterproof makeup removal and be patient while removing it.🕰️ *I keep it for more than one day and my eyelashes are fine.😍

It’s very nice,i love it

It’s ok

I love this mascara. It makes my lashes look very, very thick and very, very long, and it's also very black. It's Exactly what I was hoping for! I bought another mascara that is also a fiber lash, and it isnt even close! This Vibely mascara looks like I have triple the lashes. You have to be careful how you apply it, because it can definitely clump. So you just watch that you don't have too much on your brush and then just keep stroking until you get the clumps off and it looks beautiful. It looks like you're wearing fake lashes!