VARIETY AWAITS - Explore a range of flavors from dark to white chocolate!
INDULGE GUILT FREE - Enjoy a delicious treat that's gluten-free and responsibly sourced!
12 PACK CONVENIENCE - Perfect for sharing or keeping all to yourself!
NUTS FOR SUSTAINABILITY - Crafted with local ingredients for a minimal carbon footprint.
RAINFOREST ALLIANCE CERTIFIED - Support sustainable cocoa farming with every bite.
Justin's Organic Milk Chocolate Peanut Butter Cups are a deliciously indulgent treat made with organic, non-GMO ingredients. Each 12-pack contains two cups per pack, featuring Rainforest Alliance Certified cocoa and gluten-free, responsibly sourced palm oil. Perfect for those who care about sustainability without compromising on taste.
Reviews
4.5
All from verified purchases
R**G
Taste, quality ingredients
Dangerously yummy!
B**B
On the reg
No weird preservatives or artificial flavors. Once you try Justin’s, it’s hard to go back to Reese’s. These peanut butter cups feel like an elevated, gourmet version of a childhood favorite.
W**N
So THIS is what an organic chocolate peanut butter cup tastes like
Back around Halloween, I saw that there was an organic Reese’s and Hershey bars. Intrigued, I bought both. Despite I was never a peanut butter cup fan, I discovered I preferred the Reese’s. They’re good. Last week, I wanted to order more—I’ll buy three boxes at a time—but they had only one box left. I bought it, but I wanted more than one box. I’ve lost a lot of weight so I eat two packs a day as a treat but to also try to gain the weight back. I saw Justin’s organic peanut butter cups and although they are pricier, I bought one box until they have more Reese’s in stock.HOWEVER, once I tasted Justin’s, it was over. Sorry but I don’t believe I’ll be buying Reese’s again. This is phenomenal. Seriously, the chocolate is so rich, the peanut butter tastes the way homemade peanut butter tastes, the kind where the oil rises and you have to stir it. I cannot believe how good these are. So I decided to set up subscribe & save for delivery every two weeks.Seriously, treat yourself to something fantastic. This! !
A**R
So Good
I love these! They are so smooth and taste very natural. I feel less guilty eating this because it is organic and natural.
J**N
Old
This product is good when it’s fresh but all of them were a light color and dried out like they were old.
C**S
A+
Top tier buttercup
J**J
Only buy it in stores
I have been buying this product in the store like Whole Foods and it is fabulous!! To get more quantity I purchased this on Amazon and was very disappointed because obviously they don’t know how to ship it chocolate to keep it fresh. The order just was not fresh where when I pick this up in the store, the peanut butter is nice and creamy and the peanut butter was not From Amazon and you can tell the chocolate melted a bit. This would have 0 stars but you have to put something.
J**S
Your two major food groups, all in one snack. Peanut butter and chocolate!
Your two major food groups, all in one snack. Peanut butter and chocolate!
Common Questions
Trustpilot
TrustScore 4.5 | 7,300+ reviews
Fatima A.
Best international shipping I've ever tried. Worth every penny!
3 days ago
Sneha T.
Received my product in pristine condition. Great service overall.
","image":["https://m.media-amazon.com/images/I/71FD8vFcdAL.jpg","https://m.media-amazon.com/images/I/61RfOyZN33L.jpg","https://m.media-amazon.com/images/I/71RsTUu-tFL.jpg","https://m.media-amazon.com/images/I/81OJ4oR5vxL.jpg","https://m.media-amazon.com/images/I/61RfOyZN33L.jpg"],"offers":{"@type":"Offer","priceCurrency":"USD","price":"48.61","itemCondition":"https://schema.org/NewCondition","availability":"https://schema.org/InStock","shippingDetails":{"deliveryTime":{"@type":"ShippingDeliveryTime","minValue":38,"maxValue":38,"unitCode":"d"}}},"category":" chocolatecandy","review":[{"@type":"Review","reviewRating":{"@type":"Rating","ratingValue":"5.0"},"author":{"@type":"Person","name":"R***G"},"datePublished":"March 15, 2025","name":"Taste, quality ingredients","reviewBody":"Dangerously yummy!"},{"@type":"Review","reviewRating":{"@type":"Rating","ratingValue":"5.0"},"author":{"@type":"Person","name":"B***B"},"datePublished":"February 14, 2025","name":"On the reg","reviewBody":"No weird preservatives or artificial flavors. Once you try Justin’s, it’s hard to go back to Reese’s. These peanut butter cups feel like an elevated, gourmet version of a childhood favorite."},{"@type":"Review","reviewRating":{"@type":"Rating","ratingValue":"5.0"},"author":{"@type":"Person","name":"W***N"},"datePublished":"April 21, 2024","name":"So THIS is what an organic chocolate peanut butter cup tastes like","reviewBody":"Back around Halloween, I saw that there was an organic Reese’s and Hershey bars. Intrigued, I bought both. Despite I was never a peanut butter cup fan, I discovered I preferred the Reese’s. They’re good. Last week, I wanted to order more—I’ll buy three boxes at a time—but they had only one box left. I bought it, but I wanted more than one box. I’ve lost a lot of weight so I eat two packs a day as a treat but to also try to gain the weight back. I saw Justin’s organic peanut butter cups and although they are pricier, I bought one box until they have more Reese’s in stock.HOWEVER, once I tasted Justin’s, it was over. Sorry but I don’t believe I’ll be buying Reese’s again. This is phenomenal. Seriously, the chocolate is so rich, the peanut butter tastes the way homemade peanut butter tastes, the kind where the oil rises and you have to stir it. I cannot believe how good these are. So I decided to set up subscribe & save for delivery every two weeks.Seriously, treat yourself to something fantastic. This! !"},{"@type":"Review","reviewRating":{"@type":"Rating","ratingValue":"5.0"},"author":{"@type":"Person","name":"A***R"},"datePublished":"April 28, 2025","name":"So Good","reviewBody":"I love these! They are so smooth and taste very natural. I feel less guilty eating this because it is organic and natural."},{"@type":"Review","reviewRating":{"@type":"Rating","ratingValue":"4.0"},"author":{"@type":"Person","name":"J***N"},"datePublished":"May 29, 2024","name":"Old","reviewBody":"This product is good when it’s fresh but all of them were a light color and dried out like they were old."},{"@type":"Review","reviewRating":{"@type":"Rating","ratingValue":"5.0"},"author":{"@type":"Person","name":"C***S"},"datePublished":"April 28, 2025","name":"A+","reviewBody":"Top tier buttercup"},{"@type":"Review","reviewRating":{"@type":"Rating","ratingValue":"1.0"},"author":{"@type":"Person","name":"J***J"},"datePublished":"April 27, 2025","name":"Only buy it in stores","reviewBody":"I have been buying this product in the store like Whole Foods and it is fabulous!! To get more quantity I purchased this on Amazon and was very disappointed because obviously they don’t know how to ship it chocolate to keep it fresh. The order just was not fresh where when I pick this up in the store, the peanut butter is nice and creamy and the peanut butter was not From Amazon and you can tell the chocolate melted a bit. This would have 0 stars but you have to put something."},{"@type":"Review","reviewRating":{"@type":"Rating","ratingValue":"5.0"},"author":{"@type":"Person","name":"J***S"},"datePublished":"January 26, 2025","name":"Your two major food groups, all in one snack. Peanut butter and chocolate!","reviewBody":"Your two major food groups, all in one snack. Peanut butter and chocolate!"}],"aggregateRating":{"@type":"AggregateRating","ratingValue":4.375,"bestRating":5,"ratingCount":8}}
