Magnolia Bakery Classic Vanilla Banana Pudding Cookies

These are incredible. I love all things banana. But not fake banana like circus peanuts or Laffy Taffy. Real banana. And that's what you get with these cookies. And they are also soft and chewy. They're not inexpensive but with something high quality that is to be expected.

Smaller than the cookies you get at the actual storefront location, but they taste exactly the same! Very good flavor and soft!

I was really hoping to like these because I refuse to pay the expensive shipping for the actual banana pudding. I thought the cookies would satisfy that craving, but no. They are too sweet and just not really good. I could only take eating one cookie, I took the rest to work and placed in the kitchen for anyone to grab.

Not so great…tastes very mid.. not worth the price

They tasted artificially flavored - and that must have been because they were. I was disappointed because of the bakery’s reputation. Good cookies are when I open the box or bag and cannot stop eating until the box or bag is empty, That is my own little taste test and proof of the pudding! It took me weeks to eat those three boxes of expensive cookies and I thank God there were only four in each box…. They should have paid me to eat them! Unfortunately, I had a disappointing experience…. Y’all, I am from the South and I know what the taste of good Banana Puddin’ is! There is no fooling me! I can go through a whole serving bowl of Banana Puddin’ in no time flat when it tastes natural and there is no “chemical” taste. I just want to think that some one just baked a bad batch. I really owe it to them to test them again, but at my age, life is just too damned short…. I am old and cranky, so do not mess with my Banana Puddin’…

Mmmm, banana pudding cookies. Yes, please. Since I had the opportunity to try two different flavors, this review will cover both.Vanilla with white chocolate chips banana pudding cookies: Also delicious. And again, I think it would be great as ice cream sandwiches.Chocolate chunk banana pudding cookies: These are quite tasty. I was a bit concerned that they would be too sweet, but I like them and they were less sweet than the vanilla with white chocolate. They’re soft baked with delicious chunks of chocolate in them, which also makes them ideal to make ice cream sandwiches.Overall: These are definitely melt-in-your-mouth cookies and I love that they come individually packaged, so I can toss them in my bag to eat at lunch or as a snack. They smell and taste strongly of banana, which is appreciated and tasty. If anything, we decided that they would taste better with salty macadamia nuts added; although I can appreciate the desire to have them be somewhat allergen free, we did feel like they needed something more—in the way of salt and crunch.

Good for the taste buds but bad for the diet. A soft cookie with a banana scent. Addictive. I didn’t realize I ate that many cookies!

These cookies are soooooo good. I shared them with some coworkers and they loved it. Zap these in the microwave for 10 seconds. You’ll thank me later. :-)