All Natural Puppy Peanut Butter Training Treats - Low Calorie Dog Treats – Low Fat Diet for Pets - Vegetarian, Baked, Crunchy Biscuits - Heart Shaped, Healthy Fiber, No Grain-Gluten, Made in USA

Limited healthy ingredients(oat flour, peanut butter, chia seeds, blueberries). Not too hard, not too soft. Mostly arrived whole pieces some crumbs. My dog isn’t picky at all so she loves them (anything with peanut butter). Unless you’re strictly grain free diet, these are a great healthy treat. Slightly expensive but worth a dogs joy and well being. Rather pay a little more than less for most dog treats that are filled with chemical preservatives and other unhealthy ingredients that are harmful to their health and dogs don’t need in their diet at all.

The only comment I would have to make is that for the size and quantity, these are a little pricey. I expected to pay somewhere around $6.99 for an 8 ounce bag (which is still pretty expensive), not $11.99 plus tax. That's 24 dollars a pound!!!! For that I can get a 40 pound bag of highest quality dog food.! But I'm not a normal buyer of them. I only buy these when I petsit for a certain family, and they never leave me enough for the time they are gone. They don't even know I buy the extra. Their dog does like them though, and I know they are health conscious about the dog and have been using them for several years, so I guess Paws Up, guys!

I love the limited, healthy ingredients (oat flour, peanut butter, chia seeds, blueberries) and the cute heart shape, while my pup seemed to love the perfect little crunch and peanut butter as the first ingredient! After a day or so of getting these treats, when he heard the package opening, he would come running! :) I ended up breaking the treats in half or even thirds to use for training purposes, which made the bag last a lot longer. We will definitely keep these treats in the rotation. It's nice to have 1 meat free option without any junk ingredients or chemical fillers, which are actually super unhealthy for dogs (we also keep on hand freeze-dried beef liver treats and freeze-drived salmon treats) .

My two smooth fox terriers love these treats. They must taste great because they gobble them down (I haven't tasted them myself, but they sure do smell good!) I also like that they are low calorie because, at age 11, the pups don't have that svelte waistline anymore. They came on time, fresh and I will continue to purchase them as special treats.

Why did you pick this product vs others?: These are excellent training treats for al dogs! Big and small, young and old. Natural ingredients and healthy for dogs.

The price continues to go up, and the size of the bag has gone from 8 oz to 7 oz. My dogs love these treats. I've purchased 16 bags of them over the last few years. $10.99 for an 8 oz bag in 2020, which was expensive enough, is now $13.99 for a 7 oz bag. They've priced them out of my reach. Sad, but the bag that was delivered today will be my last. I'm sure we'll find another healthy treat they like for a much more reasonable cost.

I opened the bag and the healthy ingredients smell so good, and I’m sure delicious by the reaction of our dogs loving them. Product is excellent and recommended.

After watching Luck Dog training tips, I searched for the best training treat I could find. The IMK9 Natural Training Treats Low Calorie, is the perfect solution. According to my pups, they taste great, smell good and don't crumble. This order was a test purchase. My next ones are for sustainability... Thank you.