Julep When Pencil Met Gel Long-Lasting Waterproof Gel Eyeliner, Soft Black

I was pleased with this pencil in that it was easy to apply and did stay put, so no more panda eyes. Problem is that because it's so soft it needs sharpening after every couple of applications and it's not that easy to sharpen. the first time the lead came off completely. To give it benefit of the doubt I've bought a new, supposedly top quality sharpener but I'm not sure how long it will last if I've got to sharpen it every other day it could work out expensive.

I like this the best of all I've tried. I like to line my waterline and these go on so smoothly and come off when I wash them off. Dry quickly. Great price and quality. Covers easily

Great idea but when it comes to sharpening the tip very difficult so had to throw it away! A total waste of money 🙁

Has a tendency to skip and clump a little but stays on pretty well.

This gets five stars (it won't allow me to select the second star for some reason). This is one of the longest lasting eye pencils I've ever used and I've tried them all! IT. Sephora. Lancome. Estee Lauder. You can't beat the price point. The only place I had to freshen up by the end of the day was the corners of my eyes. It makes a great liner for under my eyes and smokes out beautifully. I also used it to line my upper lids and it stayed all day without smudging or transferring. This makeup snob highly recommends the Julep eye pencil.