When Pencil Met Gel Sharpenable Longwear Gel Eyeliner Pencil (Clay) High-Performance, Waterproof, Transfer & Smudge Proof Eyeliner

This is sooo good! Soft, smudgeable but not messy and a lovely pigment. So surprised at the quality to be honest will definitely buy again. Easier for me to use than some other more expensive brands I’ve used that drag on my skin or even break at the tip. Definitely recommend. Should add I have sensitive eyes and they have taken no umbrage with this eyeliner. Whahoo

Lovely, long lasting colour. Really easy to apply. And very affordable.

This pencil is good, however twice now I've got to the end of the pencil, and I would say about a third had nothing in. If this happens again I will not be purchasing this item again. 😑

Lovely colour and super smooth application. But definitely not waterproof and definitely not smudge proof.

I have been using this pencil in Smoky Plum for a few years now, love the colour, glides over the eye area without pulling, good price, I have slightly oily skin around the eyes so use a little concealer just to secure the colour stays put, but on normal skin your probably fine.

Great idea but when it comes to sharpening the tip very difficult so had to throw it away! A total waste of money 🙁

Very soft, glides on nicely, good colour, easy to sharpen.

I don't often buy eye pencils as they drag on skin and then disappears when my eyes water, as I seem to react to lots of make up. But this feels quality, more like a very soft crayon, not waxy but glides on so soft can barely feel it and is not sticky. Colour looks gorgeous but not glittery and best of all it stays on all day even if my eyes water, but comes off easily with elemis make up remover. Highly recommend, especially if you're on wrong side of fifty and nothing stays!

Je ne l’ai pas encore utilisé mais sa couleur est bien celle que je souhaitais.

Excelente lápiz para ojos. Mi favorito. Cremoso, fácil al aplicar y dura todo el día perfectamente. Resalta muy bonito los ojos verdes.

These are hands-down the best eyeliners I have used in quite some time. I have tried super cheap, drugstore pencils, expensive name brands that cost $30-$40 for a pencil, and these are amazing. They are easy to sharpen, which I like, I like a very sharp point, and they go on easily, but they are not so soft that they don't apply precisely. They are the perfect mix of soft/hard. Very easy to glide on my eyelids, and you have around 5-8 seconds to smudge it or clean up smears, or I use my finger nail to swipe up the liner at the end of my lashes. After that time, the eyeliner stays put, it will not budge. It is amazing, it doesn't smear off, it doesn't bleed out under my eyes or on my eyelids (I have always gotten eyeliner on my eyelids by end of day. I must have oily eyelids, not gross, but very moisturized or something). This comes off easily with Micellar water and I wash with face wash. I purchased the dark brown (which is very dark brown, nearly black), the glittery brown (so pretty and not as harsh as the dark brown, the clay (pretty light, but still pretty) and the dark green (haven't worn yet but it's pretty). These are such a great deal and I expect them to last 6-8 months, depending on how much you use them. I know some people don't like to sharpen their eyeliners, but I do. It's the only way to get a precise point and create thin lines, in my opinion. Get a good sharpener. :)

Long lasting and easy to apply eyeliner. I love the teal color against my brown eyes.

Muy buena lápiz delineador. Pinta fácilmente y dura todo el día.