Smucker’s Natural Creamy Peanut Butter, 16 Oz. Jar

The best peanut butter!

I have had to stay away from Peanut Butter for decades as most of them have a lot of added oils and additives that have given my stomach and body problems. I had seen years ago the fresh made PB in the gourmet stores, but it was always so expensive. Then i saw Smucker's' Natural PB at Amazon Fresh one day and i have been addicted to since. Even more impressive was the low price for the large jar too. Peanut oil does settle at the top, caution when opening. You could drain it out or mix it with the PB. This so is so good and with just simple ingredients, Peanuts & Salt, such a healthier alternative and so tasty. After the first time i had this, i even sent Smucker's a love letter saying thank you. Heck, i always have a jar around and it rarely gets put away

My new favorite peanut butter with tiny peanut grounds that provide texture. No hydrogenated oil or preservatives besides salt. Be sure to take the time to stir in the natural peanut butter oil. Be patient and keep stirring properly. I just use a knife to stir. Great natural taste and the sweetness of roasted peanuts.

Good product at a good price.

Just peanuts & salt

I’ve been buying many brands of peanut butter lately to compare & possibly select a new brand as I had become extremely disappointed in the quality decline of a brand I have been consuming for most of my life. Smucker’s was the 5th up in my trials and I wanted to taste test it immediately. I didn’t even settle the jar in my pantry with all the others on trial. I was positively appalled when I opened the jar soon after delivery to find a JAR OF OIL with something that looked sort-of like a peanut slurry. I could not even drain the oil off as the “peanut butter” was also going down the drain!! I then stuck a thin bladed knife to the bottom of the jar thinking the thick butter would be settled there, BUT NOT SO. It was just as slimy as the rest of the jar. Big, white, all cap letters on the front of the jar declared “CREAMY”, but this was anything but creamy - it had literally thousands of tiny bits of unground peanuts throughout that felt like beach sand in my mouth. POSITIVELY REPULSIVE !!! Sorry Smucker’s. Needless to say this brand will NOT be a contender to replace the brand I’ve used for years. I’m now thinking of grinding my own peanut butter as Amazon has a large bag of peanuts at a very reasonable price that are quite tasty. I have been using them for many months in a variety of recipes, some cooked, some as-is out of the bag as toppings or just a handful as a snack.

Best natural peanut butter on the market and Amazon Fresh can't seem to get their inventory management system fixed so it's ALWAYS OUT OF STOCK. They haven't figured out yet that if I have to go to the grocery store for one item, I'm going for all of them and not going to use Amazon Fresh.

I think people have started to forget what real food looks like without preservatives, stabilizers, or thickeners. Only two ingredients, no sugars at all — you just need to mix it well. The price is great for this kind of product. I bought it to try and didn’t regret it.