stila Smudge Stick Waterproof Eye Liner | Long-Lasting Color Wear, Smooth Glide Eyeliner Pencil or Eyeshadow

I have a hard time finding this eyeliner in stores. It is so easy to use. It is thin so you can add to make the line thicker. I like a thin more natural line during the day and thicker if going out for a night ob the town

This is the best eyeliner I have ever used. The color was perfect and just glided right on. Stayed on all day. And stayed perfect all day. When I took it off in the evening it came right off. I love it and will be buying more. And I’ll be trying some different colors. It’s the best!!!

I have this in Stingray, the black color, and the brown color, Lionfish. It applies easily, and smudges like a dream with a brush. It also stays in place all day, as long as you don't physically touch it. It lasts for over 8 hours in an office environment or a good cry without primer and if you add primer it's still perfect after a 4 hour workday, a 5 hour drive, and a rock concert.I have a warm complexion with a golden undertone and even smudged I find that this color, the Stingray, is a bit harsh for me, I think it's a cool toned black. I use a crease brush to add dark brown eyeshadow on top. The Lionfish is a warm, light brown Mocha color, it would be nice for a natural look but I don't use it often because I have blonde eyelashes and no brown mascara at the moment. I've had some success blending the two colors. I plan to buy more shades in the future.

The Stila Smudge Sticks are one of my favorite eye liners. They come in lots of great colors. I've been wanting to try (but haven't been brave enough yet!) a couple of their brighter colors like the Purple Tang or the Deep Fuchsia but so far have only purchased the Damsel, Stingray, Metallic Umber, and Alpine -- some purchased from Amazon and some from a brick-and-mortar store (Ulta).The liner is easy to use and really does last better than most other liners that I've used. I'd doubted that the fact of it being waterproof would really help it to last on my eyes. I was afraid that the "waterproof-iness" of it would only be affected by things like actual water--tears and rain and such--but that the liner would still disappear over the course of the day due to skin oils and the oils in my eye cream. But, most days, my liner still looks the same in the evening as it does in the morning--and I can't say that about most roll-up stick liners that I've used. On days that I know that I'll be in the hot outdoors for extended periods, I'll add a bit of eye primer first to help keep both my liner and my eye shadow from disappearing. But it's usually not necessary for this liner.The pigment stick twists up as you use it and need more. So far, out of the many Stila liner pens I've purchased, I've only encountered one recalcitrant pen that didn't want to twist up more liner. I held the pen with the open liner "tip down" and flicked it with my finger a few times mid-way on the pen, while twisting the pen to extrude more liner. It finally started working again.Of the four colors that I've purchased so far, my very favorite is the Metallic Umber, with Damsel being a close second. They're my go-to, everyday liners. The umber isn't overly dark and it's also just barely metallic. Since I have pale blonde hair, I feel that the Damsel is a better choice for me as a dark liner than the Stingray, although I have used the glossy black Stingray for some evenings when I wanted more drama. I bought the pearly Alpine to use on my waterline but I don't use it all that often.

This is a game changer for anyone that their mascara always smudges or smears or bleeds on to your under eye. I don't do alot of reviews but when you have a product that works this good for this price you have to!!Thank you for making something that I can wear all day. It also doesn't irritate my eyes where most products do estee lauder, clinique, even my favorite Limelife after a long day of wear it also smudges so I got my length and fullness but I looked like i had black eyes after a few hours. I am very satisfied would've given 10 stars

The pigmentation of this eye liner is very good. True to its color. It also glides onto the eye very easily. The design of the packaging is very good as well. Being an auto eyeliner stick, the fact that it never needs to be sharpened is really good. No hassles with wooden shavings and colored mess. Yet its claim to be waterproof is not credible. If I use this on my upper or lower water line, it smudges like crazy and I can always count on it to smudge onto my lower lashes by the end of the day. If I line my upper lashes, it creases and if I line my lower lashes, it smudges. For the price, I don't think the quality of the product is up to par. I am sure there are much better, less expensive alternatives to this eye liner.

I love this brand, and am disappointed to see they are discontinuing their full line of colors - or at least I can't find them in stock when I click on them. I use this to line my upper lid just under the lashes, and it always goes on smoothly. Because it comes in a plastic dispenser, it never scratches my eye the way wooden eyeliner pencils do. It stays put all day, and comes off with eye makeup remover easily at night. I'm so glad I found this brand, its what I've been looking for for ages.

I will never forgive stila if they discontinue this color. I LOVE IT so much for my green eyes. I wish it didn’t smudge so much, but it’s worth it because I can’t find a color like this anywhere else.