Tarteist Double Take Eyeliner-black by Tarte

works very well for me. I’m a 64 year-old woman. I use this on my upper and lower lids. I don’t use very much but it lasts all day long. It’s easily removed with your cleanser. It does not smudge for me. it is dual ended one and is a coal. The other is more of a felt tip for fine lines. I feel it is worth the money and lasts a very long time.

Took too many tries to remove with makeup remover, and soap. Gave up and had to try again the next morning after sleeping with raccoon eyes! Sent back!

I had this sitting in my cart for a long time and finally purchased it. shockingly good eyeliner. I used to use liquid but as I got older it started being too hard to get the straight line that I like. so I switched to the kind in the little pot that you brush on. used that for a long time, until I finally tried this. swipes right on in a straight pretty line just like when I was in my early 20's. doesn't irritate, doesnt smudge, stays on all day all night, and washes off cleanly and easily. took a few minutes off my makeup routine, which i can definitely appreciate. Haven't tried the pencil side yet and still curious how long this will last before it starts drying out. I'll update when I find out

This eyeliner seriously delivers. I wore the Tarte Double Take Eyeliner for over 12 hours in below-freezing weather, with rain, wind, and eyes literally watering from the cold and it did not budge. No smudging, no fading, no running. It truly lasted all day exactly as promised. The pencil goes on smoothly and the liquid side gives bold, precise definition. Love that it’s waterproof, vegan, and cruelty-free too. If you need an eyeliner that can survive real life (and brutal weather), this is it.

I like tarte eyeliner. It has staying power. It's nice to have different options of application with each end being different. It's a very good value for a long lasting liner that's good quality. It goes on super smooth and resists smudging. I know I'll be back for more.