Too Faced Killer Liner 36-Hour Gel Eyeliner Pencil | Long Lasting, Waterproof, Non-Flaking Eyeliner Pencil, 0.04 Ounce

Eyeliner is a critical part of my beauty routine. I often don’t wear shadow at all, just winged liner. So I’m very good at judging liner quality. Having mature skin further complicates my “perfect eyeliner” quest. I prefer the soft, gentle glide of potted gel liners. However, I find that it’s more difficult to apply a winged, sleek line with a brush. When I discovered that “Too Faced” now makes eyeliner, I knew it had to be good. This glassy slick gel pencil glides on beautifully AND lasts up to 36 hrs. I love it!!! I have removed this liner with a bit of Clinique brand “Take the Day Off” and a make up wipe (Neutrogena). In a pinch, just a wipe will suffice, tho it does tug a bit. Rich pigments tattoo your eyes with color and beautiful wings. Once easily applied, it must be removed. My tecnnique is great, but you don’t need anything special; just a steady hand. Colors are so good!! Deep, silky brown and midnight inky black. It’s always perfect and stays put until you take it off!

Best eyeliner! I love how smooth it goes on and no smudges. I will be purchasing it again.

This eye pencil stays on forever! I have very oily irritable skin around my eyes and this is the most waterproof product I've ever used! It IS a little difficult to sharpen, but it's still worth it!

The pencil worked great at first. It is difficult to sharpen and breaks off leaving a sharp wooden edge. It does not stay longer than a few hours and smears.

Goes on smooth. Had a hard time when it came to sharpening pencil.

I love this eyeliner! It goes on so smooth & easy. Also it doesn't smear.

This is my everyday eyeliner without a doubt. It is soft and applies smoothly to a mature eye lid. Lasts all day and doesn’t smear. The killer espresso is the perfect black/brown color - not as harsh as black can be.

Update: This is not the eyeliner that I've used in the past. I didn't realize it was now a pencil enclosed in plastic, making it almost impossible to sharpen. Also, it dries out quickly and flakes off onto my face. For me, this is a waste of money. I use the black eyeliner, and like that the ingredients are safer than most other eyeliners out there, but unfortunately it doesn't last very long. If I apply it in the morning, by the afternoon the liner has dissolved a bit, leaving only a very thin line. Also, it's not a smooth application, sort of pulls on my eyelid and takes a while to build. Will keep using until I can find another safe alternative.

This liner did not stay on.. it smudges on both upper and lower lids..