GigaBite Beef Esophagus Dog Treats - Natural Gullet Sticks for Dogs, High Protein Single Ingredient Dog Chews, Rawhide Free Dental Dog Treats for All Dog Breeds - Sticks (6 Inch), Pack of 25

Update: Just noticed the listing description says they are esophagus chews, but the section for ingredients and a label on the bag state they are made from bladder. My dog doesn’t mind (he hasn’t learned to read yet), but I don’t appreciate the false description. I left a 5-star rating because my dog does love them and hasn’t had any problems with them. My dog loves these. He eats them right up—they aren’t a long-lasting treat like bully sticks. They are a bit pricey, so I only give one every 2-3 days. But the 6” size is fine for my 60 lb dog and I figure the crunchy texture is good for cleaning his teeth. They have a little cow smell, but it’s not bad to me. I haven’t noticed any staining on my rugs from these treats, but my dog eats them so fast they don’t sit on the floor very long!

I got these for our most recent litter of Labradoodle puppies to take home with them in their puppy packs and the puppies absolutly loved them and so did Mom but they definitely don't last as long with my adults. They're great for providing a distraction and also a positive associations to the crate! They keep them occupied during their first car rides and most recently for us a plane ride! We sent home this adoable 8 wk old Labradoodle puppy "Mia" as a carry-on with her new Mom and she said she gave her the gullet chew when they were waiting for the plane and by the time they got on the plane.. she chewed it for a little while more then passed out the rest of the flight!! SO, Highly recommended!! Puppy approved and better for puppies because their softer on their teeth then other natural chews and bones and they don't stink up the place like bully sticks. I don't think the other passengers would of appreciated that for sure!! Will definitely be buying again and these are also a GREAT price! My husband recently bought 6 of these at Pdtsmart for 20 bucks! 10 bucks for a package of 3!! So these are also a steal of a price! EDIT: In response to the 1 star reviews. Dont expect a "Bully CHEW Stick" because these are NOT bully sticks. Adults will chew these down in seconds flat. They're pretty uniform in length.. about the length of a pencil but they all do look slightly different in length and width. They shouldnt look perfectly the same anyway... "Bully sticks" are actually made from the penis of a bull and beef gullets are made from the "esophagus" of a cow. Beef gullets are a good source of chondroitin, which is good for growing joints and general joint health. Beef Gullets and Beef Spizzle or Penis are two completely different textures.. Gullets are thinner skinned and more of a delicate body part of a cow. I wouldnt say "hollow" but definitely no as hard or chewy as a compact dried bull penis.. Guess "Bully" stick does sound more appealing to the masses but lets also be logical here. Not the same body parts at all. I've also never had an adult dog or puppy get diarrhea from these BUT some dogs are more sensitive to Beef and beef organs and some are allergic to Beef period. It's actually one of the most common food allergies in dogs. None of these issues are the fault of the company or the product. BTW I've never spoken with this company, my review is 100% honest. I've purchased these several times and given them to all ages of dogs. I'll definitely edit it again if their quality changes. Just ordered a new box! Jan 2020! Happy New Year Dog Lovers!

My dogs go absolutely crazy for these. As soon as I open the bag they’re all over me. They’re soft enough that my small dogs can actually chew them comfortably without struggling, which is a big plus. I wouldn’t give these to larger dogs because they’re pretty soft and they’d probably swallow them way too fast. I like that they’re single ingredient and all natural. That makes me feel better about giving them as a regular treat. No weird fillers or junk. They seem fresh when you open the bag and the texture is consistent throughout. Yes, they do have a smell, but that’s normal for natural beef treats and honestly my dogs think it’s the best smell in the world. For the amount you get, the price is really reasonable. Just make sure to supervise while chewing like you would with any treat. Overall, these are a staple in my house for my small dogs.

looks like a good deal but the sticks are incredibly thin so they dont last as long as one might hope. there are certainly a lot of sticks in the bag. my dog likes them, no major complaints

This bag was packed so full! I have a large Doberman puppy that loves these things. Of course, she chews them down within minutes but it is a nice pacifier and helps to keep her teeth clean. A small dog could chew for hours! Not much odor at all, if any. Great price for the amount received. True bully sticks, no rawhide. Digests fine. I will definitely purchase again.

Bought a bag of 40 was only 33 told them got another bag only had 35, dont advertise 40 sticks if your going to short it! Too expensive especially with 2 doggies, my dog love them but they have tummy aches ...they eat em way to fast

This is my dogs favorite treat of the day! She gets very excited for her stick treat! They do have a bit of an unpleasant smell but… so does my dog sometimes. So is life.

My dog with a sensitive stomach/prone to pancreatitis flare ups was loving these. We’ve gone through easily 7 or 8 batches. However, the different batches are wildly unpredictable. I noticed the last batch was a lot thicker and kind of lumpier than I’ve ever seen them. I chalked it up to nature since they are a part of an animal. He ended up pooping blood after the first one in this batch. A pancreatitis flare up so bad he passed out. My fault for not thinking of this but for anyone with a dog that is sensitive to fatty or rich foods, I’d look elsewhere. Pic of my boy waiting at the vet with his lethargic painful eyes.