
Desertcart purchases this item on your behalf and handles shipping, customs, and support to USA.
The WINNER of 11 Academy Awards* including BEST PICTURE is now 50 minutes longer! This extended version of the epic conclusion of The Lord of the Rings trilogy includes new score by Howard Shore and over 350 new digital effects shots. The greatest trilogy in film history, presented in the most ambitious sets in DVD history, comes to a grand conclusion with the extended edition of The Lord of the Rings: The Return of the King . Not only is the third and final installment of Peter Jackson's adaptation of the works of J.R.R. Tolkien the longest of the three, but a full 50 minutes of new material pushes the running time to a whopping 4 hours and 10 minutes. The new scenes are welcome, and the bonus features maintain the high bar set by the first two films, The Fellowship of the Ring and The Two Towers . What's New? How Are the Bonus Features? One DVD Set to Rule Them All Peter Jackson's trilogy has set the standard for fantasy films by adapting the Holy Grail of fantasy stories with a combination of fidelity to the original source and his own vision, supplemented by outstanding writing, near-perfect casting, glorious special effects, and evocative New Zealand locales. The extended editions without exception have set the standard for the DVD medium by providing a richer film experience that pulls the three films together and further embraces Tolkien's world, a reference-quality home theater experience, and generous, intelligent, and engrossing bonus features. --David Horiuchi Review: An artful and tasteful conclusion to the triology (details) - The three *The Lord of the Rings* films [all directed by Peter Jackson] have clearly made film history, chiefly due to their marked overall excellence. This film trilogy, shot entirely in New Zealand, is breathtaking at a minimum. Here, I'm reviewing the *Special Extended Edition* [as opposed to the much shorter Theatrical Version] of the third of these films on DVD, *The Return of the King*. It concludes the larger story on all fronts. I'm sure that the tale is familiar to most who would show an interest in this film but, for the uninitiated, the overall adult fantasy trilogy by J.R.R. Tolkien chronicles a group of Middle Earth travelers which include a wizard, two men, a dwarf, an elf, and four hobbits, ergo: "The Fellowship". They are set upon this quest because two evil wizards have joined forces in an effort to eventually conquer and enslave all otherwise peaceful cultures of Middle Earth which includes Hobbits, Men, and Elves. At the behest of the pair of dark and nefarious sorcerers are the most dreadful orcs, trolls, wargs, and other heinous minions. At the outset [in previous films], one of the Hobbits [Frodo Baggins] has inherited a magic ring from an aged relative [Bilbo Baggins, of The Hobbit: 70th Anniversary Edition: or There and Back Again fame, a fantasy written by Tolkien for young people] and it eventually becomes clear that this is *The One Ring* which exerts full power over all remaining magic rings of power which still exist within Middle Earth. The One Ring was originally crafted by The Dark Lord [Sauron, the more powerful of the two evil wizards] but it was inadvertently lost for many years. As The One Ring [which can render one invisible, with certain negative caveats] ultimately ends up in the hands of Frodo, it becomes his crusade and his burden (along with the rest of The Fellowship) to destroy this ring at Mount Doom, a huge volcano which lies within Sauron's sinister and well-patrolled realm of Mordor. *The Return of the King* picks up the story after The Fellowship has endured numerous battles and other notable impediments to their objective. At this point, The Fellowship has broken up into multiple segments and all but the Hobbit Frodo and his devoted companion, Sam, band together again in a final effort to divert Sauron's attention from The One Ring so that the two Hobbits can surreptiously enter Mordor and destroy it. Two spectacular battles ensue and the action is non-stop. The advantage to viewing this edition of the film [as opposed to the theatrical version] is that the story makes a lot more sense, especially to those folks who have not read the books, (now available in a single edition: The Lord of the Rings: 50th Anniversary, One Vol. Edition .) This DVD is significantly longer than the theatrical version. The trio of films broke tons of of new ground which was particularly in evidence as the cast and crew made a clean sweep at the Academy Awards for this final entry in the year of its release. The special effects were so sigificantly on the cutting edge of technology [chiefly enhanced by WETA Digital in New Zealand] that each film became superior to its prequel. *The Return of the Kings* stands today as the very hallmark of special effects technology -- it's so superb because all the characters and scenery look so realistic. No detail or necessary expense was spared in the making of this epic film. Howard Shore continued to write music for this movie which has helped to place it in such high esteem. His filmscore [available in its entirety here: The Lord of the Rings: The Return of the King (The Complete Recordings) ], coupled with segments of the soundtracks of the two previous films, are now available as a *Lord of the Rings Concert* such as this one Music from The Lord of the Rings Trilogy , these being rendered by various renowned orchestras around the globe. Some arrangements of this music vary, depending upon the conductor and the orchestra. Shore used The London Philharmonic for the movie soundtrack. This film stands on its own. You could definitely watch and enjoy it without having seen the two previous films. But I would heartily recommend that you do view the other two in the order in which they were released: The Lord of the Rings - The Fellowship of the Ring (Platinum Series Special Extended Edition) and The Lord of the Rings - The Two Towers (Platinum Series Special Extended Edition) . While it was likely that Frodo [Elijah Wood] was the central character in the film, or perhaps even Gandalf the Wizard [Sir Ian McKellan], it is the stellar performance of Viggo Mortensen as Aragorn which eclipses them all. Still, this film is perfectly cast and that was clearly half the battle for Director Peter Jackson. As with the preceding two Special Extended Edition DVD sets, this boxed set includes two *Appendices* discs [four discs total, two for the film and the two "making of" discs] which cover every possible aspect of the making of the movie. They are infinitely well-done and are nearly as compelling as the movie itself. Do not miss this historic and magnificent film, even if fantasy is not precisely your favorite genre. Highly recommended above all others! p.s. -- If you as yet own none of the three films and you wish to purchase them as a single package, you can do so here: The Lord of the Rings - The Motion Picture Trilogy (Platinum Series Special Extended Edition) . Review: As close to perfect as film gets - Like all Tolkien fans, I had once been afraid of this. I had been afraid that our beloved books would be taken by a talentless, indifferent hand and thrown into the horrendous money-making machine. I had been afraid they'd be ground mercilessly and without any consideration for J.R.R. Tolkien's work or for its fans, ground into pieces of overbudgeted FX with not much else left to the eye and to the mind. What we got instead was nothing short of a masterpiece. Hype? Sure, there's been some hype. But The Lord Of The Rings has rendered the word hype obsolete. It takes that hype and smashes it against a wall of pure brilliance. The final installment is a glorious ending to a trilogy that decades down the road, I have no doubt, will be hailed as one of the greatest achievements in modern cinema. Had I written the review right after seeing it, it would've probably consisted of one word. WHOA. But I'm OK now. I'm fine. I've taken my Advil, drank my three cups of coffee, got good five hours of sleep. I'm OK now. I can finally sit down and write a coherent review. On the other hand, do I dare? What can you say about a movie which is, for the lack of a better word, perfect? I know, I know. Of course, no movie is perfect. But this one is as damn well close to perfect as it gets. I've been literally put under a spell, very similar to the one that had seized my mind 18 years ago when I first read the books. Flaws and lowdowns? Sure, there are some, but only if you choose to be a grumpy purist who refuses to get it through his head that literature and cinema are two very different media and therefore cannot be the same, will never be the same. This is as great an adaptation as there will ever be. Call me when you make a movie one-tenth this good. In my eyes, the films are in some ways better than the books. I find it extremely annoying that Tolkien's work is being idealized by his fans. He was but a man and he, too, made mistakes. His books, as detailed and amazing as they are, still aren't perfect. There are characters who do nothing but sit around, scenes the very presence of which is meaningless or at the very least questionable. Think Arwen, think Tom Bombadil... who, while making a part of the story cool and magical, bears next to no impact on the story as a whole (of course, "true Tolkien fans" will probably have my head if they read this, but oh well). But above all, it makes my blood boil when I hear things like "a true visualization of Tolkien's Middle-earth it is not" (sic. Rogert Ebert). With all due respect, who in the world do you think you are to decide what a "true visualization of Tolkien's world" is? No one but Tolkien himself can give us the true visualization of his world, and he's been dead for decades. Peter Jackson & Co had a task in front of them akin to dragging a cross to the top of Golgotha, in metaphorical terms. And, by all that's sacred, I cannot see how a filmmaker could succeed more in such a task. It is no small feat to accomplish what they have accomplished. Not only have they succeeded, they have exceeded all my expectations. You can see and feel with every shot that this is a labor of love. That goes for everything and everyone in the movie. Cinematographically, it's amazing. The FX were just enough and never cheesy or unnecessary. The score moves you deeply - even the normally annoying Enya did not bother me this time. The acting was splendid, and the cast was simply perfect. I grew up with the characters in my heart, and now they finally have faces. I mean, how many times do you actually read a book, imagine the characters, and then see the movie and realize that the characters look eerily close to what you've imagined them to look like? I could go further into details about this particular installment, but I don't think desertcart supports reviews that long. I will simply say that I have never been one of those never-happy purists who nitpick even on the quantity of leaves on trees in Rivendell. I believe these movies should be seen for what they are, not for what they are not. Don't sit there and compare it to the book, or complain how something was added or taken away. Know this: if you want to see Tolkien's Middle Earth, you never will. Only Tolkien himself could give you his Middle Earth, and he's long gone. Look at these films from an overall point of view and try to see that it is simply impossible to film such a leviathan in a way that will make everyone happy. And for what it is, this trilogy is a rare gem. It combines end-of-your-seat action with heartbreaking drama, and brings intensity on both visual and emotional levels, which few films have accomplished so far. For me personally, it was also a memorable experience because I got to share it with a hundreds of moviegoers who sat in the theater with me for three years in a row. We watched in silence, lest we miss anything. We wowed at the sight of the dark, vast Moria, the surreal beauty of Rivendell, the fiery grandeur of Mt. Doom. We laughed at the hobbits' painfully sweet naiveté. We clapped at the grand finale. We couldn't hold back tears in the last few minutes before the credits rolled. We were there, with them, sharing this timeless tale of friendship, destiny, love, the loss of innocence and the reign of good vs. evil. Sounds trite, I know. But this is probably one story where it's not. Your mileage may vary.
| Contributor | Andy Serkis, Bernard Hill, Billy Boyd, Cate Blanchett, David Wenham, Dominic Monaghan, Elijah Wood, Hugo Weaving, Ian Holm, Ian McKellen, John Noble, John Rhys-Davies, Karl Urban, Liv Tyler, Miranda Otto, Orlando Bloom, Peter Jackson, Sean Astin, Sean Bean, Viggo Mortensen Contributor Andy Serkis, Bernard Hill, Billy Boyd, Cate Blanchett, David Wenham, Dominic Monaghan, Elijah Wood, Hugo Weaving, Ian Holm, Ian McKellen, John Noble, John Rhys-Davies, Karl Urban, Liv Tyler, Miranda Otto, Orlando Bloom, Peter Jackson, Sean Astin, Sean Bean, Viggo Mortensen See more |
| Customer Reviews | 4.8 out of 5 stars 1,177 Reviews |
| Format | Box set, Closed-captioned, Color, DTS Surround Sound, DVD, Dolby, Dubbed, NTSC, Special Edition, Subtitled, Widescreen Format Box set, Closed-captioned, Color, DTS Surround Sound, DVD, Dolby, Dubbed, NTSC, Special Edition, Subtitled, Widescreen See more |
| Genre | Fantasy, Science Fiction |
| Language | English |
| Runtime | 4 hours and 10 minutes |
P**E
An artful and tasteful conclusion to the triology (details)
The three *The Lord of the Rings* films [all directed by Peter Jackson] have clearly made film history, chiefly due to their marked overall excellence. This film trilogy, shot entirely in New Zealand, is breathtaking at a minimum. Here, I'm reviewing the *Special Extended Edition* [as opposed to the much shorter Theatrical Version] of the third of these films on DVD, *The Return of the King*. It concludes the larger story on all fronts. I'm sure that the tale is familiar to most who would show an interest in this film but, for the uninitiated, the overall adult fantasy trilogy by J.R.R. Tolkien chronicles a group of Middle Earth travelers which include a wizard, two men, a dwarf, an elf, and four hobbits, ergo: "The Fellowship". They are set upon this quest because two evil wizards have joined forces in an effort to eventually conquer and enslave all otherwise peaceful cultures of Middle Earth which includes Hobbits, Men, and Elves. At the behest of the pair of dark and nefarious sorcerers are the most dreadful orcs, trolls, wargs, and other heinous minions. At the outset [in previous films], one of the Hobbits [Frodo Baggins] has inherited a magic ring from an aged relative [Bilbo Baggins, of The Hobbit: 70th Anniversary Edition: or There and Back Again fame, a fantasy written by Tolkien for young people] and it eventually becomes clear that this is *The One Ring* which exerts full power over all remaining magic rings of power which still exist within Middle Earth. The One Ring was originally crafted by The Dark Lord [Sauron, the more powerful of the two evil wizards] but it was inadvertently lost for many years. As The One Ring [which can render one invisible, with certain negative caveats] ultimately ends up in the hands of Frodo, it becomes his crusade and his burden (along with the rest of The Fellowship) to destroy this ring at Mount Doom, a huge volcano which lies within Sauron's sinister and well-patrolled realm of Mordor. *The Return of the King* picks up the story after The Fellowship has endured numerous battles and other notable impediments to their objective. At this point, The Fellowship has broken up into multiple segments and all but the Hobbit Frodo and his devoted companion, Sam, band together again in a final effort to divert Sauron's attention from The One Ring so that the two Hobbits can surreptiously enter Mordor and destroy it. Two spectacular battles ensue and the action is non-stop. The advantage to viewing this edition of the film [as opposed to the theatrical version] is that the story makes a lot more sense, especially to those folks who have not read the books, (now available in a single edition: The Lord of the Rings: 50th Anniversary, One Vol. Edition .) This DVD is significantly longer than the theatrical version. The trio of films broke tons of of new ground which was particularly in evidence as the cast and crew made a clean sweep at the Academy Awards for this final entry in the year of its release. The special effects were so sigificantly on the cutting edge of technology [chiefly enhanced by WETA Digital in New Zealand] that each film became superior to its prequel. *The Return of the Kings* stands today as the very hallmark of special effects technology -- it's so superb because all the characters and scenery look so realistic. No detail or necessary expense was spared in the making of this epic film. Howard Shore continued to write music for this movie which has helped to place it in such high esteem. His filmscore [available in its entirety here: The Lord of the Rings: The Return of the King (The Complete Recordings) ], coupled with segments of the soundtracks of the two previous films, are now available as a *Lord of the Rings Concert* such as this one Music from The Lord of the Rings Trilogy , these being rendered by various renowned orchestras around the globe. Some arrangements of this music vary, depending upon the conductor and the orchestra. Shore used The London Philharmonic for the movie soundtrack. This film stands on its own. You could definitely watch and enjoy it without having seen the two previous films. But I would heartily recommend that you do view the other two in the order in which they were released: The Lord of the Rings - The Fellowship of the Ring (Platinum Series Special Extended Edition) and The Lord of the Rings - The Two Towers (Platinum Series Special Extended Edition) . While it was likely that Frodo [Elijah Wood] was the central character in the film, or perhaps even Gandalf the Wizard [Sir Ian McKellan], it is the stellar performance of Viggo Mortensen as Aragorn which eclipses them all. Still, this film is perfectly cast and that was clearly half the battle for Director Peter Jackson. As with the preceding two Special Extended Edition DVD sets, this boxed set includes two *Appendices* discs [four discs total, two for the film and the two "making of" discs] which cover every possible aspect of the making of the movie. They are infinitely well-done and are nearly as compelling as the movie itself. Do not miss this historic and magnificent film, even if fantasy is not precisely your favorite genre. Highly recommended above all others! p.s. -- If you as yet own none of the three films and you wish to purchase them as a single package, you can do so here: The Lord of the Rings - The Motion Picture Trilogy (Platinum Series Special Extended Edition) .
Z**Y
As close to perfect as film gets
Like all Tolkien fans, I had once been afraid of this. I had been afraid that our beloved books would be taken by a talentless, indifferent hand and thrown into the horrendous money-making machine. I had been afraid they'd be ground mercilessly and without any consideration for J.R.R. Tolkien's work or for its fans, ground into pieces of overbudgeted FX with not much else left to the eye and to the mind. What we got instead was nothing short of a masterpiece. Hype? Sure, there's been some hype. But The Lord Of The Rings has rendered the word hype obsolete. It takes that hype and smashes it against a wall of pure brilliance. The final installment is a glorious ending to a trilogy that decades down the road, I have no doubt, will be hailed as one of the greatest achievements in modern cinema. Had I written the review right after seeing it, it would've probably consisted of one word. WHOA. But I'm OK now. I'm fine. I've taken my Advil, drank my three cups of coffee, got good five hours of sleep. I'm OK now. I can finally sit down and write a coherent review. On the other hand, do I dare? What can you say about a movie which is, for the lack of a better word, perfect? I know, I know. Of course, no movie is perfect. But this one is as damn well close to perfect as it gets. I've been literally put under a spell, very similar to the one that had seized my mind 18 years ago when I first read the books. Flaws and lowdowns? Sure, there are some, but only if you choose to be a grumpy purist who refuses to get it through his head that literature and cinema are two very different media and therefore cannot be the same, will never be the same. This is as great an adaptation as there will ever be. Call me when you make a movie one-tenth this good. In my eyes, the films are in some ways better than the books. I find it extremely annoying that Tolkien's work is being idealized by his fans. He was but a man and he, too, made mistakes. His books, as detailed and amazing as they are, still aren't perfect. There are characters who do nothing but sit around, scenes the very presence of which is meaningless or at the very least questionable. Think Arwen, think Tom Bombadil... who, while making a part of the story cool and magical, bears next to no impact on the story as a whole (of course, "true Tolkien fans" will probably have my head if they read this, but oh well). But above all, it makes my blood boil when I hear things like "a true visualization of Tolkien's Middle-earth it is not" (sic. Rogert Ebert). With all due respect, who in the world do you think you are to decide what a "true visualization of Tolkien's world" is? No one but Tolkien himself can give us the true visualization of his world, and he's been dead for decades. Peter Jackson & Co had a task in front of them akin to dragging a cross to the top of Golgotha, in metaphorical terms. And, by all that's sacred, I cannot see how a filmmaker could succeed more in such a task. It is no small feat to accomplish what they have accomplished. Not only have they succeeded, they have exceeded all my expectations. You can see and feel with every shot that this is a labor of love. That goes for everything and everyone in the movie. Cinematographically, it's amazing. The FX were just enough and never cheesy or unnecessary. The score moves you deeply - even the normally annoying Enya did not bother me this time. The acting was splendid, and the cast was simply perfect. I grew up with the characters in my heart, and now they finally have faces. I mean, how many times do you actually read a book, imagine the characters, and then see the movie and realize that the characters look eerily close to what you've imagined them to look like? I could go further into details about this particular installment, but I don't think Amazon supports reviews that long. I will simply say that I have never been one of those never-happy purists who nitpick even on the quantity of leaves on trees in Rivendell. I believe these movies should be seen for what they are, not for what they are not. Don't sit there and compare it to the book, or complain how something was added or taken away. Know this: if you want to see Tolkien's Middle Earth, you never will. Only Tolkien himself could give you his Middle Earth, and he's long gone. Look at these films from an overall point of view and try to see that it is simply impossible to film such a leviathan in a way that will make everyone happy. And for what it is, this trilogy is a rare gem. It combines end-of-your-seat action with heartbreaking drama, and brings intensity on both visual and emotional levels, which few films have accomplished so far. For me personally, it was also a memorable experience because I got to share it with a hundreds of moviegoers who sat in the theater with me for three years in a row. We watched in silence, lest we miss anything. We wowed at the sight of the dark, vast Moria, the surreal beauty of Rivendell, the fiery grandeur of Mt. Doom. We laughed at the hobbits' painfully sweet naiveté. We clapped at the grand finale. We couldn't hold back tears in the last few minutes before the credits rolled. We were there, with them, sharing this timeless tale of friendship, destiny, love, the loss of innocence and the reign of good vs. evil. Sounds trite, I know. But this is probably one story where it's not. Your mileage may vary.
I**E
Restoring the King: Tolkein's Masterpiece, Fully Realized
I attended the theatrical release of *Return of the King* on December 17th, 2003, queuing in line for two hours and waiting another hour once seated in the auditorium. The energy of the room seethed with barely retrained anticipation, a tangible excitement, along with perhaps a trace of nervousness - Jackson was 2 for 3, but *King* was the watershed: the one film where all of LotR's themes, character arcs, plot development and essential tension would find climatic resolution...or else fail, either spectacularly or disastrously, rendering all that before a wasted effort. I personally had no doubts as to Jackson and co.'s abilities, and the film more than exceeded my expectations, capping the cinematic momentum of its two predecessors and paying satisfactory adaptation to the book(s) upon which it was based. And yet, a feeling of incompletion haunted my euphoria, a sentiment very much similar to my reaction to the theatrical version of *The Two Towers*. The special effects blew me away, the acting more than once tugged a tear from my eyes, yet in the end I knew what I had witnessed was a truncated version of *Return of the King*, with a rumored hour of footage left on the editing floor. The cuts were dramatic - Saruman, the Witch-King/Gandalf confrontation - and, in some places, disconcertingly obvious, the rough transitions and haphazard pacing occasionally jerking me from the spell of the film. I consoled myself that an Extended Edition would eventually `complete' the movie I had just witnessed, filling in the blank spaces and producing a much ~smoother~ viewing experience. Such had been the case with *The Two Towers*, another film that suffered in its condensed version and subsequently became a masterpiece upon the Extended release. It is my firm belief that Peter Jackson as his illustrious associates (all several thousand of them) filmed these movies to *be* a 12 hour cinematic cycle, and the demands of the in-theater attention span (and New Line's profit margin) forced into necessity the widespread and sometimes arbitrary editing process. The films themselves, when compared side by side, are testament enough; and the voluminous evidence as to the trials and tribulations of paring this four hour epic down to size, by way of the documentaries featured on this edition, set this impression in stone. Like many others, I have no desire whatsoever to re-visit the theatrical releases, the Extended being the true completed rendition of *LotR*. The additional material of *Return of the King* tends to focus on small, intimate character moments, increasing the weight and depth of the story as a whole; and in the subtle lengthening of individual scenes, turning chopped cliff-notes *LotR* into a fully realized creative scope. And what scope this is! It's easy to see why *Return of the King* amassed the box office returns and awards that it did - the film elevates all that brought forth previously, and enhances it tenfold. The battles are bigger and incredibly intense, with much more at stake; the emotional denouement of Frodo and Sam's journey, from the pastoral Shire to the hellish pits of Mt. Doom, is devastating. It helps that every aspect of the filmmaking process was taken up a notch post-production. Return of the King has the best special effects of the three movies (the best I've ~ever~ seen, to be honest), the grandest and most resonant score courtesy of Howard Shore, and an overall confidence/mastery of cinematography and scale that, on a purely aesthetic level, make *Return of the King* an artistic wet-dream, breathtakingly beautiful to an astonishing degree. And now with the original editing restored and the drama allowed its maximum impact, this film has become cinematic near-perfection, the crown jewel of Jackson's masterpiece. That said, *Return of the King* does have its share of minor flaws that even the Extended cut was unable to overcome. The opening flashback fishing scene with Smeagol and Deagol struck me as overtly goofy, especially in lue of its homicidal conclusion. The Armies of the Dead, when viewed afar, look rather fake, the only real CGI mishap. Denathor's character remains sadly underdeveloped, his madness via palantir-corruption strangely excised. And the much-hyped Witch-King/Gandalf fight comes in far too abruptly and, though I'm no purist, violates the original text. But these are minor when compared to the Lighting of the Beacons...Minas Tirith, in all its [miniature] glory...the Houses of Healing...the Ride of the Rohirrim...the entire Oliphaunt confrontation...the cataclysmic choice at Mt. Doom. At last, at long last, a fantasy world has come to life on the silver screen: a mythos has been made real. The effort involved to make it feel as real as possible is chronicled and concluded on the two Appendices discs; and, more than before, the toll it took to produce these movies, and the exactitude of craft Weta achieved, is presented with painstaking detail. Although early reports about *RotK* were positive - Jackson constantly stating that it was the easiest and most fun to make - the Appendices reveal that this was an affirmation-façade: *RotK* more than doubled the number of effects shots of the first two movies combined, and proved a nightmare for Jackson and Jamie Selkirk to (not quite) successfully edit into a cohesive whole. Particularly revealing is a section where one of the peak effects shots, that of the Oliphants colliding, was rejected due to cinematography issues: the staff went back and composed the shots in a 48 hour stretch, on the very threshold of the deadline. Amazing stuff! It's rewarding to see these artisans go up and beyond anything they thought they were capable of, and in turn fashion some of the best work in cinematic history. Filming *The Lord of the Rings* was once considered impossible by conventional standards; but with the right amount of passion, dedication and love for the source material, a little team from New Zealand surmounted all odds and produced a stunning success. Bravo!
B**F
Extended Edition a MUST for Film Fans!
I admit that I've been a GREAT fan of the Tolkien trilogy since I first read them (in the 1960's), and that I love director Peter Jackson's visionary interpretation, but I'm not going to attempt to analyze the longer (and superior) version of "The Return of the King", here...what truly makes the Extended Edition absolutely ESSENTIAL for ANY film fan are the 2 discs of additional features! If you really love filmmaking, in all of it's many aspects, you will NEVER find a more comprehensive 'primer' of the creation of a film classic! Beginning with the WWI experiences of J.R.R. Tolkien, which, combined with his love of the heroic prose epics of Great Britain and Scandinavia, and an amazing talent to create languages, led to his writing what he considered an "unfilmable" classic trilogy, the viewer is taken on a journey as magical and fascinating as the final chapter, itself. Jumping from Tolkien's source material to Peter Jackson's daunting task of not only completing the trilogy, but making the final part the greatest of the three films, we visit each area of production, with step-by-step documentary 'chapters' of how the finished film was achieved. While a 'nuts and bolts' technical overview has been done as an 'additional feature' for many DVDs, I've never seen a version more comprehensive and entertaining, because Jackson produced it, himself, and set the chapters into a timeline (from pre-production to premiere), that captures the tension and excitement of a film so large in scope and production that the final FX shots and music were not inserted until less than a week before "Return" premiered, world-wide! Fascinating stories and secrets are shared, by cast and crew...You finally meet one of the 'little people' who played a Hobbit for the long shots of the trilogy; Christopher Lee's controversial 'disappearance' from the final theatrical cut is explained; you get to see 'unused' subplots that were actually filmed (including a thankfully discarded sword battle finale between Aragorn and Sauron); in a very funny sequence, you see Jackson and many production heads, in full make-up, doing 'cameos' as Corsair pirates during a battle! There is much, much, more, and every chapter, from FX to Costume, from Sound Design to Music, are each given loving attention, and are all terrific, and great fun. As a climax, viewers are treated to the premieres in Wellington, and around the world, and get front-row seats for both the Oscars and the post-Oscar party...then get to see Jackson return to the studio to add even MORE footage to the 'Best Picture' winner, for this extended edition! See why I consider this version ESSENTIAL? To my knowledge, there has never been so much fabulous material offered in ANY 'Special Edition' DVD! This IS a 'MUST' for ANY film fan's collection!
A**R
If I could give six stars, I would
Forgive my my lack of spelling ability when it comes to the character's names! The Return of the King extended version lives up to the hype beautifully. It's true that none of the extra footage is needed, the theatrical cut tells the story perfectly. This version gives Lord of the Rings junkies more of a fix, and at just over four hours, it's a heck of a fix. The new scenes are all great and well done. The confrontation with Saruman, though not totally faithful to the book, still embodies the spirit of the all the characters involved save Frodo and Sam who were present at his demise in the book. Peter Jackson's love of gore has a slight influence in his death, something you'll have to see. The additional scenes in the house of healing added depth to Eowyn, making use of an underused character and actress in my opinion. Faramir and Denethor have more scenes including one with Sean Bean which shows the depths of Denethor's madness as well as the heartfelt tragedy of his late remembrance of his love for his other son, Faramir. Merry and Pippin get a few more lines to deliver in true Hobbit fashion, but also we get to see more of their heroic deeds that earn them so much respect from the rest of Middle Earth. Gandalf's confrontation with the Witch King is good, though it seems to start a bit forced compared to the other scene additions. Still, it's a good scene. Theoden, another character that was underused, benefits some from the additions as does Eomer. Aragorn probably has the most new scenes, including an addition to the confrontation with the King of the Dead and the attack on the Corsairs. He also gets a scene with the Palantir and confronts Sauron directly. The scene at the Black Gate with the Mouth of Sauron is great, and how it ends probably would've have audiences cheering had it been included in the theatrical release. Finally, Sam and Frodo and Smeagol get a few new additions, though not many since most of the story was focused on them anyway. The escaping the troop of marching Orcs was added, which provides a slight moment of comic relief to a very demanding ending to the movie. In addition to adding new scenes, the movie has many scenes that are extended. The Ride of the Rohirrim during the battle of the Pelanor fields is extended slightly to show even more footage of this amazing scene, probably one of the best horse charges ever filmed. The battle scenes aren't the only ones that get extra footage and they are numerous and spread out through the film. No changes were made to the ending of the film, which I have to admit, I would've liked to see them add the extra bits about what happened to rest of the fellowship. The Scouring of the Shire is also missing, which I find a blessing considering after three and a half hours of intense drama and action, more would just be too much. Many note the great battle scenes or the amazing special effects as the greatest achievement to these movies. But their true greatness lies in their ability to capture the true spirit of the story. They may not follow the book perfectly, but there's no mistaking that the message they pass along is contained within the pages of the book. The acting is superb in all of the scenes. The visual quality was improved from the theatrical DVD release (notice how the blacks actually look black instead of dark gray?) and the audio options increase. The documentaries are great though the best one is probably the one focusing on the Rohirrim. It shows the filming with the horses, which to Tolkien were very much characters in the book, and a very humorous look at the fake horse (a 40 gal barrel) used for close ups of the actors. Overall a must have for Lord of the Rings fans. Casual fans of the trilogy will be fine with the original version, but there is no way anyone who likes these movies can go without seeing this version. A true classic of our time.
M**M
!!!!!!!!!!!! HE STUNNING & VIBRANT CONCLUSION !!!!!!!!!
RETURN OF THE KING finishes the stunning trilogy of Tolkien's LORD OF THE RINGS. In this tale, Frodo & Sam continue on to foreboding Mordor while the rest of the Fellowship fights the massive armies being sent out by Sauron, the dark lord. From the movie, it would appear Jackson & creative team take some liberties with Denethor (i.e. he was controversial and stuffy but in the movie he's just an idiot), as well as leaving out the Scouring of the Shire (i.e. not enough time and anti-climatic, they say in the extended DVD of Fellowship) and what is happening over the rest of Middle Earth (i.e. in the trilogy the other areas of good are under attack, so, it's not like the other elves, dwarves and humans are sitting back). The final film has the usual elements we have grown to love: (1) snappy, funny replies from Gimli; (2) the usual competitive streak between Gimli and Legolas, which includes one part where Legolas drops an elephant and Gimli says, "That only counts as one!" (3) Sam being the heart of the film. In fact, he steals some of the best lines. Look for one of my favorites in the orc tower as he says, "And that's for me old gaffer!"; (4) Pippin getting into trouble; (5) even more epic scope battles than in TWO TOWERS (yes, even with the extended version); (6) Aragorn using his leadership to create strengh in the ranks of men . .. Gandalf helps a lot, too; (7) Gandalf using his powers to ward off evil, including the Nazgul (i.e. the flying dragons); (8) lots and lots of evil things; (9) a chance to finally see Mordor and the evil which rests within, including the creepy, slimy and chilling Shelob, a giant spider that looks too real; (10) the final erosion of Gollum's mental abilities, including a flashback to how he found the ring and slew his brother for it; (11) a stand off between Eowyn and the Witch King; (12) The charge of Rohan in Gondor, where they decimate orc ranks but then have to deal with massive elephant legions; (13) the lighting of the fires, which goes off all over Middle Earth, it seems, to call Gondor's allies to aid, as waves of orcs and other baddies arrive.; and (14) The bittersweet ending and the sailing of the last White Ship, which includes Frodo, who realizes that the ring has taken its toll on his personage and that he can't go back home again. He is emotionally scarred and after four years in the Shire he leaves on the White Ship with Gandalf, Elrond & Galadriel. The talk around Hollywood is that this film will not only be nominated for best film with the Academys but will also win. Golden Globes has given it several awards already, too. For those who have gotten nostalgiac that the series has ended, cheer up. Peter Jackson has expressed a keen interest in doing THE HOBBIT. That said, with all the money Hollywood made, I'm feeling they're going to try and also do something with THE SILMARALLION, assuming the Tolkien estate doesn't put up a huge fight, that is. Overall, a great epic conclusion to the trilogy. Look to the DVD to fill in rushed or missing slots. Purists of the novels will have their gripes; everyone else will love it.
M**N
Love the serious moments, hate the comic relief.
I was finally able to watch my ROTK EE last evening and I have to say many of the new scenes are great. I love the scenes added that are closer to the book such as the houses of healing and the prose from Legolas before the paths of the dead which closely mirror Tolkein's writing. But I have to say some of the new scenes are cringe-worthy, mainly having to do with Gimli. I just loved Gimli in the books, his person was one of bravery and honor, and much pride. I am so upset that Jackson has relegated him to almost constant silly comic relief. Jackson assumes that his audience can't handle the dread, despair, and fear that Tolkien instilled in his fellowship in the books. Yes they still had hope, but they struggled with fear and doubt knowing what awaited them. SPOILERS AHEAD!! In the books as Gimli went into the paths of the dead he was struck with such fear (and of course it was total darkness in the cave, I understand this would not relate to film) that he was crawling on his hands and knees in absolute terror, yet he wen't in because in the end he was honorable and brave and a true friend of the fellowship. This scene in the books was so terrifying, yet in the film Jackson mainly makes it a comedy. Gimli blowing at the spirits as if they are candles is such a lame way to film this scene. His tap dance on the skulls is ridiculous. The drinking game was another scene where I was sitting there saying "you have to be kidding me, this is not lord of the rings. Gimli passes gas, goes cross-eyed and falls out of his bench backwards as his feet sprawl in the air----what? This is not the Gimli I know. I can handle a few off key laughs as much as the next person, I just can't stand this slapstick routine that insults our intelligence(not to mention poor Gimli's mangled character in these films). I wish I could delete the forced comedy in these movies myself. Jackson still did a great job with the trilogy, because the scenes that are good (most of them) are so very very good as to cover a multitude of ones that are not. And did you notice that the most beautiful scenes and the most beautiful dialog are straight from Tolkien's book. Peter Jackson is great with action and emotion, but the comedy schtick has got to go. Like I said I can understand some comedy and laughs in a time of peril if it is used in context of the characters trying to alleviate their fears, but some of these scenes are just too silly and take you out of the moments that Tolkien implied for you to feel. Even still four stars because the strong points of these films are very strong. I love these films, but I love more what they could have been had they not strayed from the formula laid down by Tolkien.
D**S
The Ultimate DVD Experience
Alas. I am bleary-eyed from lack of sleep. My hair looks like an abandoned bird's nest. I've been wearing the same pair of underwear since. . .Tuesday, I think. That long-neglected salisbury steak TV dinner still resides in the microwave. Peter Jackson, you have successfully hijacked countless hours of my life with your extended version of THE RETURN OF THE KING. I know I should complain--complain about the insomnia, lack of appetite, mold in my undies--but can't bring myself to do it. These four DVDs are a Tolkienite's blissful nirvana, and I, after hours and hours of eager viewing, have only just begun to scratch the surface of their abundant treasures. For abundance is the watchword with this majestic extended version, beginning with the film itself. Well over four hours in length, we are greeted and treated with exceptional extra footabe. The violent demise of Saruman and Grima Wormtongue. A jarring exchange at the Black Gate with the "Mouth of Sauron" (oh, for a good dentist). Brief, fleeting glimpses at the blossoming romance of Eowyn and Faramir. Frodo and Samwise, clad in Orc garb and deep within the festering bowels of Mordor, suddenly absorbed into a most dysfunctional brigade. And those are just for starters. The extended version of THE RETURN OF THE KING wonderfully and successfully enhances, augments, and improves the Academy Award-winning theatrical release; its special features and enticing appendices make watching this stuff an absolutely unforgettable experience. As examples: We learn why the "Scourging of the Shire" was not included; how Tolkien himself was influenced by the wanton carnage of World War I; the overwhelming emotions of the actors as they concluded their roles after more than four furious years of filmmaking--heck, we even get to watch a gigantic prosthetic oliphant get made and then transported, piece by piece, via dozens of trucks, to some windblown pasture, where it becomes the world's largest movie prop. No wonder I haven't showered in days. This extended version is the granddaddy of its two predecessors--a shining triumph of entertainment guaranteed to enchant and delight. Pay close attention to the actors' voice-overs of the extended film; you will laugh, giggle, chuckle (what a witty group they are)--but you will learn, and absorb, a ming-boggling amount of information. Most highly recommended. --D. Mikels
N**C
Warning: scene spoiler
I have the extended versions of the first two parts of LOTR, so this was a welcome addition to my collection. It has my favourite scene: Gandalf describing the passing of the soul at death into "the far green country under a swift sunrise", the basis of Annie Lennox's final song, "Into the West". Marvelous! The added scenes suggesting the romance of Faramir and Eowyn (so moving in the book) make sense of the one surviving clip in the theatre version of them greeting the Return of the King side by side in the crowd. The scene with the Mouth of Sauron (with his admittedly wonderfully creepy mouth) is shockingly inappropriate. Apparently it didn't occur to the writers that envoys and ambassadors were "sacred persons" in ancient cultures, and to murder one (as the Orcs murdered the carrier of the red arrow to King Theoden of Rohan) is a base and despicable act, utterly inconceivable for the lordly King Aragorn. A sad comment not only on today's failure to live by noble ideals but even to comprehend them.
H**R
Only Way to Watch Lord of The Rings
Arrived as expected, and was in good quality. I had lost my original copies and was really disappointed, but I decided to take a chance on this order and I was so happy. Love the Extended Version of the whole Lord of the Rings movies, it is the only way to watch it. All of the behind the scenes moments are incredible, I also recommend the cast commentaries, I'd you need a laugh listen to Billy and Dominic. The Director and producers give so much in-depth insight on the vision you just feel like you could listen non-stop. I need the Extended Edition of The Hobbit next.
L**S
Perfect Story Imperfect Disc
This is one of my favourite stories so this is a review of this disc and purchasing process. The disc delivers tine was 3 weeks. There were 2 small glitches in the disc which was annoying as this is a replacement for a disc I already own. I have decided to keep it anyway
J**M
The gripping conclusion to "The Lord Of The Rings" trilogy
This whole series is wonderful. It is a well-told story that somehow juxtaposes massive battle scenes with touching moments of humanity. Classic film making that stands the test of time and still touches people. Love it!
J**E
les informations supplémentaires.
Une très bonne série à conserver. La version longues donne tellement plus de détails et d'information. Un trésor pour les collectionneurs.
Trustpilot
2 days ago
1 month ago