5 Inch Commercial Quality Melamine Windproof Ashtray - Navy Color

I just received your ashtray in green as I asked and the only thing I would change is the top should screw onto the bottom to keep it together in a strong wind or accidental knocking it off the table. As far as the hole size, I think it's made to stick the cigarette in until it snuffs itself out, then you put in the bottom half of the ashtray. I like it, but decided to use it for my small porch and order a larger one for my breezeway.

The holes fill up pretty quick. You'll need a nail or something to clean them out. I do like how the holes put out your cigarette quickly, though, so it's worth the minor inconvenience.What would it take to give it a 5?- The holes wouldn't fill up so quickly- Made of a more durable plastic or ceramic- The top & bottom fit together better

Arrived as seen in the picture. Choice of color was not allowed, which is why I gave this product four stars rather than five. But this product otherwise serves it's intended purpose. Works great as an ashtray, and pulls apart into two pieces, allowing easy removal of butts.

The holes where you are supposed to snuff out the cigarette were too small. I drilled them out and they work fine now. I also have the bigger ash tray, 8 or 9". Buy that one instead it works great.

This ashtry was perfect for outside smoking. The cigaretted didn't blow out of the ashtry and the hole were very easy to extinguish the cigaretted. The only problem was that if the wind blew the ashtry off of the table, it broke easily.

Arrived chipped but I used the product on a cruise ship and loved the way it worked there, that's why I purchased it.

Exactly what I was looking for. They are small BUT they do the job that I knew they would. Maybe I should have ordered the larger one but again: they are perfect and definately what I wanted. I am happy with them and I recommend them to anyone who has checked them out online.

I don't smoke. This is for my husband. He likes it.