Voluminous Smoldering

My go to eyeliner, have purchased more than one. The liner goes on smooth and lasts. Easy to apply, price is worth it. Excellent quality

Forever a favorite. Been using it for years. Has the best color payoff. Good price. And lasts a long time. Quality is great and easy to use for beginners.

I've been using this pencil liner for years and will continue to use it. I've never been a fan of liquid liner so this is perfect for me. It goes on smoothly, doesn't smudge...just all-around good quality.

Let me preface my review by saying that I'm not the most knowledgeable when it comes to makeup. I know how to apply eyeliner, eyeshadow, mascara, lipstick, and concealer - but that's the extent of it, and it's certainly not a daily occurrence. That being said, I've been wanting to branch out more and try to "up" my makeup game. After reading someone's blog post that included a link to this eyeliner, and her rave reviews of said product, I decided to buy it - as eye makeup is the one thing I can *really* get down with. It was crazy easy to apply, super dark and heavy looking (FYI for those who want something a little more understated), and I loved it from the get go. My first time wearing it was to a Thanksgiving family gathering and I found myself running to the bathroom constantly. That's because, before leaving my house, I noticed that every second a smear/circle/smudge would appear at the "crease" of my eyes. I'd rub it off easily enough and then...blink, blink, blink...it'd be back. Now - this may be because I used too much, or because I didn't know anything about "setting spray/powder" that's supposed to keep your eye makeup from doing this. But I definitely developed a complex that evening - hence running to the bathroom mirror often to rub the smeared semi-circle that I had known was back. I've since bought this "setting powder" stuff all those makeup pages talk about, and have learned a few extra tricks on how NOT to have it smear like that, so I'm still very happy with the purchase. However, I know I'm not the only one in the world who doesn't know every little thing one could possibly know about the makeup world, so just wanted to warn/prepare someone who's thinking of buying this that: 1.) It's great, easy to apply, very dark and beautiful. 2.) It *WILL* smudge/smear/give you half-moons above your eyes unless you apply eyeshadow or setting powder over the eyeliner. 3.) I have no regrets! :)

This came in perfect condition and worked very well. The pencil is soft and smudgey (it's meant to be) easy to apply to the waterline. Since I use it for the waterline and not for a smokey eye, the smudginess is a double-edged sword, since some of the liner migrated down below one eye. I guess I need to use a really light hand. But after I removed the runny bit, it lasted the night without running further. It was cool weather, though. I'm quite happy with this pencil overall. I just have to be careful with the runniness. I'm sure that means it blends well for this who do like a smokey eye. My eyes are too small and deep set for that. It's black but not harsh. The formula is nice and smooth. A quality product. I will come back and edit this if I have more issues with running when the weather heats up. I am including a picture, although it's on my upper waterline so not super visible. But I'm only wearing the liner (upper waterline only) and some mascara on my eyes, and I think it did a nice job of making them more intense.

Absolutely love how it goes on it doesn’t really stay on all day. I kind of have to reapply it but very easy application and I love the pigmentation! I’ve hit the top a few times and it’s pretty durable

I had been looking for a soft, creamy eyeliner pencil that would also last for several hours, since this and mascara are the only things I use in my daily makeup routine for work. For me, it worked.

Just love this smooth eye pencil! Emphasizes my eyes without tearing my sensitive skin apart.

Thank you, L’Oreal. I had gotten to the bottom end of the one I got when I went to visit my parents last Christmas. It is the only eyeliner that doesn’t bleed or smudge, when used on the inner part of the eyelid. Amazing as always;)

Good product

Se crayons est immortel ,gras, très intense ,tiens très bien sûr la muqueuse j'avais le mien depuis des années et je l' avait perdu il est très difficile a trouver petit et gros c'est l'original alors prenez en deux direct sérieusement vendu avec un taille crayon il est vraiment magnifique

Le encanto a mi madre, ya es el segundo que pido.

In assoluto il migliore. Permane praticamente tutto il giorno e cala veramente pochissimo